TO GOOD MORNING AND WELCOME TO
THE FIRST HEARING OF THE
ASSEMBLY SELECT COMMITTEE ON
SOCIAL HOUSING WE HAVE A FULL
LINE UP TODAY THE SPEAKERS FROM
ACROSS THE COUNTRY AND AROUND
THE WORLD TO SPEAK TO THE
HISTORY OF PUBLIC HOUSING
INCLUDING MODELS FROM EUROPE
AND MEXICO THAT WE CAN LEARN
FROM AND WE REALLY WANT TO
ESTABLISH A NEW FRAMEWORK FOR
SOCIAL HOUSING AND THE BIG
OBJECTIVE HERE FOR ME AND MY
COLLEAGUES A SOME OF WHOM ARE
GONNA BE JOINING HER WHOLE GET
AN OPPORTUNITY TO SPEAK SOME OF
WHOM WILL BE. WATCHING HIS
STUFF WILL BE WATCHING THIS
FIRST TO LISTEN AND LEARN AND
THINK ABOUT NEW INNOVATIVE WAYS
WE CAN TACKLE OUR HOUSING
CRISIS HERE IN CALIFORNIA.
BEFORE WE DIVE INTO SOCIAL
HOUSING I NEED TO ADDRESS A FEW
HOUSEKEEPING ITEMS. IN ORDER TO
PROTECT THE RIGHTS OF ALL WHO
PARTICIPATE IN THE LEGISLATIVE
PROCESS AND ENSURE EFFECTIVE
DELIBERATION AND DECISION
MAKING ON THE CRITICAL ISSUES
FACING. CALIFORNIA I WANT TO
MAKE SURE EVERYONE UNDERSTANDS
OF THE ASSEMBLY HAS RULES TO
ENSURE WE MAINTAIN ORDER AND
RUN AN EFFICIENT AND FAIR
HEARING WE APPLY THESE RULES TO
ALL PEOPLE WHO PARTICIPATE. IN
OUR PROCEEDINGS IN ORDER TO
FACILITATE THE GOAL HEARING AS
MUCH FROM THE PUBLIC WITHIN THE
LIMITS OF OUR TIME WE WILL NOT
PERMIT. CONDUCT THAT DISRUPTS
DISTURBS OR OTHERWISE IMPEDE
THE ORDERLY CONDUCT OF
LEGISLATIVE PROCEEDINGS WE WILL
NOT ACCEPT DESTRUCTIVE BEHAVIOR
BEHAVIOR THAT INCITES OR
THREATENS VIOLENCE EVEN VEILED
THREATS. PLEASE BE AWARE THAT
VIOLATIONS OF THESE RULES MAY
SUBJECT YOU WHICH REMOVAL OR
OTHER ENFORCEMENT PROCESSES.
DUE TO THE COVERED NINETEEN
PANDEMIC WE HAVE LIMITED SPACE
FOR THE PUBLIC TO PARTICIPATE
SO WE CAN ENSURE EVERYONE
MAINTAINS SIX FEET OF SOCIAL
DISTANCING. IN ADDITION THIS
YEAR WE WILL AGAIN BE COMPLYING
WITH ALL PUBLIC HEALTH ORDERS
ARISING OUT OF THE COPA
NINETEEN PANDEMIC FOR THOSE
JOINING US IN PERSON THERE IS A
MASSIVE REQUIREMENT IN PLACE
FOR ALL INDIVIDUALS IN THE
HEARING ROOM YOU ALL SEEM TO BE
A BITING THANK YOU FOR THAT. AT
FOR THOSE JOINING US REMOTELY
THERE WILL BE SPACE TO PROVIDE
PUBLIC COMMENT AT THE
CONCLUSION OF THE SECOND PANEL.
TO MAKE PUBLIC COMMENT. PLEASE
CALL OUR PUBLIC TOLL FREE
NUMBER. AT. EIGHT SEVEN SEVEN
SIX NINE TWO EIGHT NINE FIVE
SEVEN. AND USE THE PUBLIC
ACCESS CODE. ONE THREE ONE FIVE
ONE EIGHT FIVE ZERO WHICH I
BELIEVE. IS ON THE SCREEN IF
YOU ARE STREAMING THIS. THIS
INFORMATION CAN BE FOUND AT WWW
DOT ASSEMBLY DOT CA DOT GOV
FORWARD SLASH TODAY'S EVENTS.
FOR THOSE CALLING IN TO LEAVE
PUBLIC COMMENT COMMENT PLEASE
SIMPLY STATE YOUR NAME
ORGANIZATION AND POSITION. I'D
ALSO LIKE TO HIGHLIGHT THAT WE
HAVE A DEDICATED LINE WHERE
THIS HEARING IS BEING
INTERPRETED FOR SPANISH
SPEAKING LISTENERS IF YOU WOULD
LIKE TO DIAL IN AND ACCESS
SPANISH INTERPRETATION. PLEASE
CONTINUE WATCHING AS USUAL ON
THE ASSEMBLY LIVE STREAM AND
DIAL INTO THE FOLLOWING NUMBER
ON YOUR PHONE. THIS NUMBER WILL
ALSO BE AVAILABLE ON THE
BACKGROUND SLIDE THROUGHOUT THE
HEARING. SIX NINE. NINE ZERO
ZERO. SIX EIGHT THREE THREE AND
THE MEETING ID IS EIGHT SEVEN
SIX. ONE EIGHT NINE ZERO TWO
FOUR ZERO ZERO AGAIN THAT
NUMBER IS ONE. SIX SIX NINE
NINE ZERO ZERO SIX EIGHT THREE
THREE AND THE MEETING ID. IS.
876-189-0240 AND ALL THESE
NUMBERS WILL BE AVAILABLE ON
THE BACKGROUND SLIDER SHOULD
YOU NEED TO ACCESS THEM AGAIN
THROUGHOUT THE HEARING. IF YOU
WISH TO MAKE A COMMENT SPANISH
DURING THE Q. AND A PORTION OF
THIS PROGRAM. PLEASE CALL TO
THE PUBLIC COMMENT LINE IS
NORMAL AND OUR INTERPRETER WILL
ASSIST WITH TRANSLATING YOUR
COMMENT FOR THE COMMITTEE AND
FOR THE RECORD. WITH ALL THAT
SAID LET'S TALK ABOUT THE
GOALS. OF THESE HEARINGS FOR
THE SELECT COMMITTEE ON SOCIAL
HOUSING. WITH THESE HEARINGS WE
AIM TO ONE DEFINED SOCIAL
HOUSING AS IT FITS WITHIN THE
STATE OF CALIFORNIA. TO
FACILITATE COLLABORATION FROM
LAWMAKERS AND STAKEHOLDERS ON
THIS NEW CONCEPT. AND THREE
OUTLINED POLICY RECOMMENDATIONS
AND BILL IDEAS FOR THE
LEGISLATURE TO CONSIDER IN THE
FUTURE. TODAY WE WILL FOCUS
SPECIFICALLY ON THE HISTORY OF
PUBLIC HOUSING WITHIN THE
UNITED STATES AND EXPLORE
MODELS THAT EXIST IN MEXICO
SPAIN AND AUSTRIA. BUT BEFORE
WE DIVE INTO THOSE PANELS I'D
FIRST LIKE TO SHARE. UGH IF
BEFORE WE DIVE INTO THOSE-
REMARKS I'D FIRST LIKE TO
OFFER- MY FELLOW COMMITTEE
MEMBERS- ASSEMBLY MEMBERS BONTA
AND LEE TO FIRST TURN AT- TO
HAVE THEM SPEAK TO WHY THEY
WERE HERE AND WHY THEY WANT TO
PARTICIPATE IN THE SELECT
COMMITTEE LET'S START WITH-
NUMBER LI FIRST. OKAY WELL I
WANT TO THANK MY COLLEAGUE FROM
THE MY COLLEAGUES FROM THE SAY
ACTUALLY FOR HOSTING THIS A
FIRST OFFICIAL. SELECT
COMMITTEE HEARING ALSO HOUSING
THING CITING OPPORTUNITY TO BE
ABLE TO LEGISLATIVELY
OFFICIALLY TALK ABOUT THIS
TOPIC. I THINK AS WE MAKE THE
PROGRESS TO LEGALIZING AN
AUTHORIZING HOUSING TO ADDRESS
THE REAL. NEED FOR HOUSING IN
THIS ENTIRE STATE WE ARE NEED
TO ALSO THINK ABOUT WHO IS ABLE
TO CONSTRUCT IT AND I THINK WE
NEED TO GIVE THE TOOLS ALL
LOCALITIES. AS MANY TOOLS AS
POSSIBLE. AS POSSIBLE TO WITH
ME OUR HOUSING NEEDS I CAME UP
HERE THIS MORNING FROM SAN JOSE
WHICH IS THE SECOND MOST ON
AFFORDABLE PLACE TO LIVE IN THE
NATION. AND WE NEED TO MAKE
SURE THAT WE HAVE THE SOLUTIONS
FOR OUR LOCALITIES TO BUILD.
MIXED INCOME AFFORDABLE HOUSING
DEVELOPMENTS ACROSS THE STATE
TO MEET IMMENSELY THAT EXISTS-
I'M REALLY EXCITED TO LEARN
FROM OUR- SPEAKERS TODAY FROM
ACROSS THE COUNTRY AS WELL AS
ACROSS THE GLOBE BECAUSE AS-
EVEN THE CALIFORNIA LIKES TO
OUR HORN AS BEING THE FIFTH
LARGEST ECONOMY THE WORLD WE
ALSO HAVE A LOT OF ROOM. TO
LEARN FROM OTHER COUNTRIES
OTHER STATES SO REALLY EXCITED
FOR OUR HEARING TODAY. THANK
YOU. GOOD MORNING AND I WANT TO
THANK CHAIR WORKS FOR AT. FIRST
IN A INITIATING THE SELECT.
COMMITTEE ON SOCIAL HOUSING.
AND SECONDARILY FOR INVITING ME
TO PARTICIPATE AS A- THE NEWEST
MEMBER OF THIS COMMITTEE- I. AT
I BELIEVE AS CHAIR WITH SAYS
THAT WE'VE SPENT THE LAST
SEVERAL WEEKS ACTUALLY
TRAVELING ACROSS THE STATE.
EXAMINING ISSUES ACROSS THE
STATE RELATED TO HOUSING
HOUSING AFFORDABILITY IN
PARTICULAR. AND AND IT'S SO
CRITICAL THAT WE ARE AT A AT
TWO. FOUR TO ADDRESS IN ORDER
TO BE ABLE TO ADDRESS THE
AFFORDABLE HOUSING CRISIS THAT
WE TAKE SOME BOLD. BOLD ACTION
I THINK CHAIR WORKS AS-
ESTABLISH AN OPPORTUNITY FOR US
TO REALLY THINK ABOUT. THE WAY
THAT WE CAN INTEGRATE SOCIAL
HOUSING INTO THE FABRIC OF OUR-
OF OUR NEW CALIFORNIA- I GREW
UP. IN THE BRONX IN NEW YORK
CITY WHERE THERE WAS. A LOT OF.
OF PUBLIC HOUSING THAT WAS
THAT. WAS QUITE CHALLENGING TO
SEE IT WAS NOT WHERE WE WANTED
TO LIVE- AS WE WERE GROWING UP
BECAUSE IT WAS THE HOUSE OF. OF
CRIME OF A LOT OF ISOLATED
POVERTY. AND I'M THANKFUL THAT.
WE'RE PUTTING FORWARD WITH THE
EXAMINATION THAT WE WILL DO. AN
OPPORTUNITY TO CREATE A NEW
DEFINITION ON SOCIAL HOUSING
UNDER CHAIR WICKS'S LEADERSHIP.
AND KNOW THAT WE HAVE AN
OPPORTUNITY TO MAKE SURE THAT
WE HAVE. AFFORDABLE HOUSING FOR
EVERYBODY- THAT ALSO INTEGRATES
AND HAS AWARENESS AROUND. HOW
AFFORDABLE HOUSING AND PUBLIC
HOUSING IN PARTICULAR HAS-
BEEN- RECEIVED AND CREATED KIND
OF AN ISOLATING EXPERIENCE FOR
A COMMUNITIES OF COLOR IN
PARTICULAR SO. I'M THANKFUL TO
THE P. BE ABLE TO PARTICIPATE
IN THIS COMMITTEE IN THAT WAY.
AND LOOK FORWARD TO EXPLORING
THE BOLD TRANSFORMATIVE AND
INNOVATIVE BOTTLES- THAT WE CAN
LEARN FROM FROM. OTHER PARTS OF
THE COUNTRY A COUNTRY IN THE
WORLD. THANK YOU AND I JUST
WANT Q. THE OPERATOR- BEFORE
PANEL BEGINS WE WERE WERE
SUPPOSED TO BE DOING FROM SLUM
JACK- OPERATOR IF YOU COULD.
SEE IF YOU COULD LET HIS LINE
COME THROUGH I KNOW I THINK
HE'S HAVING SOME DIFFICULTIES.
GEN THANK YOU. PRESS STAR THEN
ONE AND WILL BE ABLE TO TAKE
YOUR NAME. GETTING ANY RESPONSE
THERE. I AM NOT UNDER THE TIME
YEAH OKAY OKAY FROM HOPEFULLY
HE'LL BE ABLE TO DIAL IN MAYBE
PERHAPS LATER IN THE HEARING I
ALSO JUST WANNA TAKE NOT
PERTAIN TO SAY HOW EXCITED I AM
NOT HAVE BOTH ASSEMBLYMEMBERS
LEE AND BONTA HERE ON THE
COMMITTEE AND- I'M ONE OF THE
NEWER MEMBERS BUT THEY ARE EVEN
NEWER THAN ME. AND I THINK
REPRESENT YOU KNOW A NEW- NEW
LEADERSHIP AND HOUSING WHICH IS
VERY EXCITING FOR OUR ASSEMBLY-
ASSEMBLY AND I CO AUTHOR SOCIAL
HOUSING BILL TOGETHER HE'S BEEN
A CHAMPION ON. TENNIS ISSUES
AND HOUSING AND HOUSING
PRODUCTION UNAPOLOGETICALLY
LEADING ON THIS ISSUE AND THE
SOME OF A RESPONSE AND I.
ASSUME ABOUT TONIGHT JUST AS
SHE SAID TRAVELED THE STATE- ON
THE HOUSING TOUR AND I'VE HAD
MANY CONVERSATIONS AROUND THE
NEED TO WORK ON THIS AND IF
SHE'S READY TO ROLL PER SLEEVE
SO. I'M THRILLED TO HAVE BOTH
OF THEM- SOME MORE BONTA TOOK-
ASSEMBLY MEMBER DAVID CHIU SPOT
WE ARE BOMBS TO LOSE HIM- HE'S
BEEN SUCH A FIERCE ADVOCATE ON
SO MANY THINGS BUT- THRILLED-
TO HAVE- MISS BONTA STEP INTO
THE ROLE. OF FILLING DAVID CHIU
ISSUES HERE ON THE SELECT
COMMITTEE- SO WITH THAT I WANT
TO- START OFF WITH OUR FIRST
PANEL. TODAY WE HAVE- DR ROBERT
WEINER EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF
THE CALIFORNIA COALITION FOR
RURAL HOUSING AND DR EDWARD- GO
SEE THE PROFESSOR OF THE-
HUMPHREY SCHOOL OF PUBLIC
AFFAIRS AT THE UNIVERSITY OF
MINNESOTA- THE THEY WILL BOTH
HAVE- SIGNIFICANT TIME TO
PRESENT. AND SHOULD PROVIDE FOR
US A REAL- SORT OF CONCEPTUAL
FRAMEWORK AROUND SOCIAL HOUSING
AND THEN- WE WILL HAVE Q. AND A
FROM- MYSELF AND OUR COLLEAGUES
AT TO THAT END SO- WITH THAT-
DOCTOR WHEN ARE YOU WITH US
HERE. YES I'M HERE HERE. WE
CAN'T SAY OH THERE WE GO WE SEE
YOU NOW YEP. OKAY ALL THESE TO
ASSURE MY SWEET. YOU MAY. OKAY
OKAY. GOOD MORNING THE
GENTLEMAN AND MEMBERS OF THE
COMMITTEE MY NAME IS ROB WEINER
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF THE
CALIFORNIA COALITION FOR RURAL
HOUSING WHICH IS THE SAME ONE.
THE COMMUNITIES PRIVATE AND-
DEVELOPERS OPERATORS AFFORDABLE
HOUSING I AM ALSO CONTINUING
LECTURER IN THE UC DAVIS
COMMUNITY AND REGIONAL
DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM. I'LL HAVE
TO DRESS OF FOUR ISSUES. TRYING
TO DEFINE MEDIA SOCIAL HOUSING
TO TALK ABOUT SOCIAL HOUSING IT
CALIFORNIA AND U. S. COMPARED
TO OTHER COUNTRIES. TO GIVE A
BRIEF SUMMARY OF THE NINETY
YEAR HISTORY OF YOUR HOUSING
PROGRAMS. MY IDEA FOR GROWING
THE SO HOUSING SECTOR
CALIFORNIA ESPECIALLY PRIVATELY
RENTED HOUSING. TO SOCIALLY
RENTED HOUSING. SERVICE NATION
THAT HAS NOT DEVELOPED BY YOUR
ORGANIZATION FOR ECONOMIC
COOPERATION AND DEVELOPMENT
WHICH IS A NATIONAL ASSOCIATION
OF ABOUT THIRTY EIGHT COUNTRIES
AND ALL READ IT THE STOCK OR
RESIDENTIAL RENTAL
ACCOMMODATIONS PROVIDED THAT
SUB MARKET PRICES IN ALLOCATED
ACCORDING TO SPECIFIC RULES
RATHER THAN ACCORDING. TO
MARKET VETERANS. HELLO THAT
DEFINITION IS QUITE DURABLE
COUNTRY TO COUNTRY- THE
DEFINITION OF COUNTRIES ARE
DIFFERENT AS WELL AS WHAT
COUNTS AS SOCIAL HOUSING. WHAT
ARE THE OBLIGATIONS AND
CONDITIONS OF OPERATING SOCIAL
HOUSING AND WHO OPERATES SOCIAL
HOUSING. I AM VERY FROM TO
COUNTRY SO LET'S TALK ABOUT THE
SOCIAL HOUSING SOCIALLY
SOCIALLY RENTED HOUSING- IS IN
THE U. S. IN CALIFORNIA.
GENERALLY THIS IS HOUSING THAT
HAS DEEP RESTRICTIONS THERE ARE
RECORDED AGAINST THE PROPERTY.
YEAH HOLLY RESTRICTIONS THEY'RE
OFTEN FORCED TO REGULATORY
AGREEMENTS BETWEEN FLOODING
AGENCIES AND SPONSOR OF THE
HOUSE. THESE RESTRICTIONS
TYPICALLY. ARE BASED ON INCOME.
EXTREMELY LOW INCOME VERY LOW
INCOME LOW INCOME AND MODERATE
INCOME. ALSO THERE ARE
REGISTRATIONS THE RAINS
GENERALLY ARE GLOBAL MARKETS IN
CALIFORNIA UNCONDITIONAL
RESTRICTIONS SUCH S
OCCUPATIONALLY RESTRICTED
FARMER HOUSING. LUTICIAN THESE
ARE DECISIONS TYPICALLY OPPOSED
TERMS OF AFFORDABILITY WE
SHOULD CALIFORNIA RANGE
GENERALLY FROM THIRTY TO FIFTY
FIVE YEARS BUT IN SOME CASES
LIKE CONVENTIONAL CALLED
HOUSING. D. FOUR W. SUPPOSED TO
THE PURPOSE. IN CALIFORNIA THE
REST F THE COUNTRY- V.
OPERATORS OF SOCIAL HOUSING ARE
YOUR HOLLOW AGENCIES. PRIME NON
PROFIT ORGANIZATIONS OR FOR
PROFIT FIFTIES NOW ARGUABLY
SORT OF HOUSING MAY ALSO
INCLUDE SOCIALLY ALL UNITS AND
YOU LEARN IN SPAIN. THIS FORMER
CO HOUSING LIMITED OR NO EQUITY
COSTS YOU ADDRESS WE'RE- GOING.
TOWARD CRISIS CONTROL. FINALLY
THERE'S THREE ON THE SORT OF
HUNG CENTER IN MANY COUNTRY
AROUND WORLD UNFORTUNATELY. DUE
TO THE SHORTAGE OF THOSE A
SOCIAL SETTING MANY SOCIAL
WELFARE COUNTRIES. VERSION OF
THE SORT OF HOUSING STOCK TO
MARKET RATE HOUSING. SO
CALIFORNIA WILL SET THE STAGE
FOR THE REST OF THE WORLD. THIS
CHARGE JONES GRAPHICALLY THAT
UNITED STATES IS NEAR THE
BOTTOM OF ALL OF ANSWERED
PRAYER COUNTRIES. HE PERCENTAGE
OF THE TOTAL HOUSING STOCK AS A
SOCIAL RENTS. IF YOU LOOK AT
LENS IS ABOUT THIRTY FOUR
PERCENT. OF ALL THE TIME STOCK
SOCIALLY RENTED AUSTRIANS ABOUT
2324% DENMARK ABOUT 22% U. K.
AROUND 17% FRANCE AROUND FORTY
PERCENT. IN THE US IS TWENTY
ARE THESE THIRTY THREE
COUNTRIES AT 4% OF OUR HOUSE.
ALSO SEE THIS CHART THAT
THERE'S A LITTLE CHANGED
PERCENTAGE OF SOCIALLY READY
HOUSING IN THE U. S. OVER THE
LAST TEN YEARS IS STILL AROUND
FOUR PERCENT. IN SOME COUNTRIES
IT'S GONE DOWN. AS I SAID IF
YOU USE GONNA DURING THIS
TENURE. I THINK THIS IS A VERY
REVEALING CHART. IF YOU LOOK AT
WHO OWNS SOME. RANDY HOUSING.
COUNTRIES U. S. SANDRA BECAUSE
70% OF THIS SORT OF HOUSING IS
ACTUALLY OWNED BY FOR PROFIT.
JEEZ WHO ARE SUBJECT TO THE
SAME INCOME TARGETING AND TO
REGISTRATIONS AS PUBLIC AND
NONPROFIT PROVIDERS WITH THIS
IS THAT WHEN TO USE
RESTRICTIONS EXPIRE AS WE SAW
IN THE EIGHTIES NINETIES AND
TWO THOUSANDS WITH THE- FIRE.
WE RESERVE YOUR CITY FIVE YEARS
THESE PROPERTIES OFTEN
CONVERGED TO MARKET RENTS.
ORIGIN CONDOMINIUM. IF YOU ARE
DISPLACED. THE US NATIONAL
AMERICA WITH THE SENATE GERMANY
IS ALSO BECAUSE IT HAS MONTH
LONG RENT CONTROLS ANY COUNTRY
IN THE WORLD. BULLY ON
CALIFORNIA WE BELIEVE WE HAVE
ABOUT FOUR HUNDRED EIGHTY
THOUSAND SOCIALLY RENTED HOMES-
THAT'S ONLY THREE POINT 5% OF
ALL HOMES. IN THE STATE 348% OF
ALL OCCUPIED HOMES THEREBY
LEADING PRESENTABLE MULTI
FAMILY HOMES SO YOU SEE WE LAG
BEHIND THE REST OF THE WORLD
FOR THE REST. OF THE UNITED
STATES. AND WHAT HAPPENS WHEN
THE SOCIAL RACIAL HOUSING
MARKET SHARES LARGE LIKE IN
AUSTRIA. OR LEVELS. WELL FIRST
THIS IS RUSH BETWEEN SOCIAL
HOUSING PROJECT. POLITICIANS
GOOD SECONDLY IT GIVES THE
SOCIAL RENTED HOUSING SECTOR
GREATER POLITICAL LEVERAGE
GREATER BARGAINING POWER
POLITICAL CLOUT. AND IT'S
EASIER WHEN YOU HAVE A PANDEMIC
OR- RT FAILURE. RIGHT
RECESSIONAL RUBEN ABLE LAWSUIT
MARKETS ASSIST USE. SO IN OTHER
WORDS THE ALSO. SOCIALLY RENTED
HOUSE MARK SHARE IS SMALL IN
CALIFORNIA IN THE U. S. WELL
THE PRIVATE MARKET DICTATES
PRICES. LULULEMON CLUBS OF THE
SOCIAL HOUSING SECTOR. ON
GOVERNMENT OFFICIALS AND THE
PUBLIC SECTOR. THIRD WE'RE LESS
ABLE PROFIT MARKET STATISTICS
WE'VE SEEN THAT IN THE PANDEMIC
WHERE THERE ARE. EIGHTY
THOUSAND CALIFORNIANS WORST
THREE HOMELESS. OR ANY GIVEN
NIGHT THERE ARE. MILLIONS OF
PEOPLE WHO ARE ON THE EDGE OF
BEING DISPLACED WHAT A LONG
SHOT AWAY FROM BEING ON THE
STREET. THAT'S WHAT I'M SMALL
SORT OF RENTAL HOUSING SENATORS.
FOR OKAY SO LET ME WALK THROUGH
BRIEFLY FOR ME STAGES OF
HOUSING PROGRAMS THE FEDERAL
HOUSING PROGRAM THEN IT GETS
FULL TIME. THE PUBLIC HOUSING.
AND THIS NOT A LUXURY THERE'S
CASE DAY. SO MANY USERS. THANKS
TO THE- ONE OF THE GREAT
DEPRESSION WHEN THE FEDERAL-
PROGRAM EMERGED. AND DURING THE
SERIES WHAT WE SAW IS A NUMBER
OF- INVASIONS THAT WERE CREATED.
WE STILL SURVIVE TO THIS DAY
FIRST OFF IS ALL THE BIRDS OF
THE MOMENT HOUSING PROGRAM.
WHICH IS TO PURCHASE FIRST IT
WAS YOU HOW'S THE SO CALLED
DESERVING POOR. LEAD TO
DEPRESSION ERA POOR WHO WERE
MADE POOR BY FIRST YEAR OUT OF
THE DEPRESSION. OF NOT
CHRONICALLY POOR. ONE OF THE
SERVERS MIDDLE CLASS AND FOR BY
THE DEPRESSION AND WAS ALSO
SEEN AS A BIG COMMERCE PROGRAM
TO CREATE JOBS. SUPPORT BILLION
STREET. FOR THE FIRST TWENTY
FIVE YEARS SO OF THE- FEDERAL
HOUSING PROGRAMS. THE ONLY
PROGRAM THAT WAS TOTALLY
FINANCED PUBLICLY DEVELOPED
PUBLICLY OWNED THE POLICY
MANAGE- HOUSING. WE ALSO.
MEMBERS OF THE RURAL HOUSING
PROGRAM. WHICH WAS DESIGNED
MOSTLY TO RESETTLE FARM
FAMILIES IN RURAL AREAS MAY BE
DISPLAYED BECAUSE THE
DEPRESSION WE NEED TO REBUILD
THE AGRICULTURAL CENTER. AND
FINING SUBDIVISION OF THE
FEDERAL HOUSING ADMINISTRATION
WHICH WAS THE INNOVATION THAT
ENCOURAGE LETTERS WHO HAS
SUFFERED HUGE LOSSES DURING THE
DEPRESSION. TO MAKE MORTGAGES.
IS WHEN WE FIRST BEGAN TO SEE
LOW INTEREST LOW DOWN PAYMENT
LONG TERM MORTGAGE WHICH WE
HAVE TO THIS VERY DAY. ANOTHER
SEVERAL THING THAT HAPPENED
DURING THE TIME YOU'RE ABLE TO
HOUSING AFTER THE NINETY FOUR
NINE WHICH IS THE END OF THIS
ON WHICH MOST OF THE FEDERAL
HOUSING PROGRAMS BUILT. IS FOR
THE FIRST TIME THE NATIONAL
GOAL OF PROVIDING ADDITIONAL.
LIVING ENVIRONMENT FOR ALL
AMERICANS. HE CREATED A ROLL.
OF SINGLE FAMILY HOME PURCHASE
AND WE ARE PROGRAM NOT JUST
FOR. ALL LOW INCOME RURAL
FAMILIES. IT LIBERALIZED ENERGY
LOAN TERMS ALLOWING FOR.
HOUSEHOLDS WHO ARE YOU LARGER
HOMES MORE EXPENSIVE HOMES.
WITH THE SPECIALLY IMPORTANT
AFTER THE POST WORLD WAR TO GO
HOME. WELL WE SAW.
SUBURBANIZATION MANY AREAS OF
THE UNITED STATES. FINALLY A
DEFINING PUBLIC HOUSING NOT
JUST. AS TEMPORARY HOUSING FOR
THE DEPRESSION ERA COR. WHAT IS
PROBLEM HOUSING FOR THE
HARDCORE WERE. NOT SURE IT WILL
TALK MORE ABOUT THAT. THIS
EDUCATIONAL. HI LOW RISES HIGH
DENSITY LOW DENSITY- WHAT
ISSUES AND YOU CAN. THIS.
COLONIAL BILL IN NORWALK
CONNECTICUT ON NOT REALLY BUT A
LOT FOR. SO STATION ON THINK-
OKAY- INTERSECTION AGE WE SAW A
REAL ARCHER FROM THE PUBLIC
HOUSING PROGRAM. THE PROGRAM
HAS BECOME LINE LEFT SAID IT
WAS STARVE STAR RESOURCES AND
SIGNED FAILED RIGHT SAID IT WAS
A SOCIALIST. JOHN BOTH ARGUED
FOR ADDITIONAL WEIGHT HOUSE LOW
INCOME PEOPLE AND THAT WAS
THROUGH STIMULATING THE PRIVATE
SECTOR- BOTH NONPROFIT SUPPORT
FORUMS TO BUILD OWN OPERATE
RENTAL HOUSING FOR A SOMEWHAT
HIGHER INCOME GROUPS THEN. LOW
AND MODERATE INCOME FAMILIES.
WE SAW THE WHOLE VARIETY.
pJOBS IT IS RAISING GREAT CITING
PROGRESS. THAT CREATED US
MACINNES LOW INTEREST LOW DOWN
PAYMENT LONG TERM LOANS INSURED
BY THE FHA LOANS MADE BY
PRIVATE BANKS AND CITY. RIVALS
FOR PRIVATE INVESTORS AND
CENTERS KIRCH FOR MANY
DEVELOPERS ESPECIALLY FOR
PRODUCE. THE OPERATOR OF THIS
HOUSING. A PAST THEIR A- TO THE
AND OF LOWER. THIS IS STAGE
THREE C. ARCHER FROM THESE
PRIVATE SECTOR PRODUCTION
SUBSIDY PROGRAMS MORAL OF THE
RELIANCE ON. RACHEL CITIZENS.
THE PROGRAM THE DEVOLUTION OF
FEDERAL PROGRAMS THE STATE'S
CITIES AND TOWNS. ON THE
SURGING SEINE GERMAN POSTMARKS.
ARE YOU ALSO HOUSING PROGRAMS.
THE INCLUDING THAT. WELL IT WAS
SIMILAR HOUSING RUSSIAN SCHEME
TO SIMULATE DEMAND THAN SUPPLY
ZERO HOURS RIGHT LET'S
SOCIALIZE. IN ORDER TO HOUSING
RATHER THAN THE BUILDERS
HOUSING. SO WE HAD THE CREATION
OF TWO WEEKS THERE'S BEEN A
PROGRAM CENTERED PROGRAM WHICH
YOU PROBABLY KNOW ABOUT AND HE
MADE- BLOCKER PROGRAM WHICH
TOOK ABOUT TWENTY CATEGORICAL
FEDERAL PROGRAMS CLASSROOMS ONE
BLOCK. OF THE OLD. ONE OF THIS
IS. TO CITIES COUNTIES INSTANCE.
THERE WAS ONE SAW THE FULL AND-
ZERO. IDEOLOGY OF HERITAGE
FOUNDATION PRESENTS MISSION ON
HOUSING. INCLUDED THAT THE
PROBLEM. THE PROBLEM WITH NOT
ADEQUATELY BUT YEAH WAS NOT AN
ADEQUATE SUPPLY. COME OF
FEDERAL PROGRAMS YOU RELY.
CITIES PRODUCTION PROGRAM
SHOULD BE TERMINATED ALL
HOUSING SHOULD BE SOLD AND
FEDERAL PROGRAMS SHOULD BE
PRIVATIZED AND DISMANTLE THE
FIRM HOUSING BUDGET WAS CUT BY
80% WE DID SEE HOWEVER THE
CREATION OF A LOCAL HOUSING TAX
CREDIT PROGRAM WHICH IS THE
MOST PROGRAM. THE UNITED STATES
AND WE ALSO THE EMERGENCE OF
HOME PROGRAM WHICH CO SIGN WITH
THE OF THE HOUSING CRISIS AMONG
THE HOMES. FINALLY OKAY TO SEE
WAS VERY. RELATIONAL POLITICS
IS HOUSING WE LOST HUNDREDS OF
THOUSANDS OF AFFORDABLE UNITS.
WE SEE THE DEMOLITION OF PUBLIC
HOUSING CONTINUED PRESSURE TO
INVOLVE BLOCK GRANTS TO STATES
LOCALITIES WE SEEN HERE IS A
LITTLE FUNDING BODIES INCREASES
AND WHAT ARE YOU COSTS. FINALLY
ESPECIALLY BUSH TO OBAMA WE SAW
PROGRAMS. TO RESPOND TO THE
FORECLOSURE CRISIS. FIVE DURING
CURRENT. D. COME PROPOSED.
ELIMINATE FUNDING FOR ALL
HOUSING REDUCE HAS BEEN RECENT
RANTS. NOT WORK REQUIREMENTS
FOR LOW INCOME PEOPLE IN ORDER
TO CONTINUE LEADING FOR HOUSING
FAIR HOUSING LAWS WERE WEEKEND.
HE DOESN'T MATTER WELL AS WE
CAN AND THEIR INTEGRATION
HOUSING POLICIES IMPOSED.
FINALLY WE HAVE THE BUILDING
BACK BETTER MATCH WHICH
CURRENTLY PROPOSES THREE
BILLION DOLLARS FOR HOUSING WE
SHOULD BE THE BIGGEST
INVESTMENT SINCE THE- NEW. I IS
LIKELY TO BE REDUCED. NO
BECAUSE- THREE ONE FIVE
TRILLION DOLLAR- ASK IS
PROBABLY GONNA BE USED TO
CLOSER SUDDENLY TWO HOURS. BY
CALIFORNIANS GROW THESE HOUSING
SECTOR ESPECIALLY TURN OVER.
BECAUSE OF. OVER ONE. ONE POINT
THREE ONE POINT FOUR NEW. FOUR
HOUSING UNITS TO MEET DEMAND.
WE CANNOT BUILD OURSELVES OUT
OF THE HOUSE CRISIS LOAN. WE
CANNOT BUILD ENOUGH UNITS
QUICKLY ENOUGH IN THE RIGHT
LOCATIONS WITH THE RIGHT FIT
WITH THE RIGHT PRICE POINTS.
MOST LOW INCOME HOUSEHOLDS IN
CALIFORNIA DO NOT LIVE IN
SOCIAL HOUSING. THEY LIVE IN
PRIVATELY RENTED HOUSING NOT A
NATION BEFORE THE SOCIAL
HOUSING STOCK IN CALIFORNIA IS
LESS THAN 4% SO WE HAVE A
MONOPOLY PRIVATELY RENTED
HOUSING OPERATORS WHAT THIS
DOES INCREASE MAJOR SERGEANT
AMERICANS WE SEE REGARDING
ECONOMIC HARDSHIP OVERCROWDED
IS A STANDARD CONDITIONS
SHELTER POVERTY AND HOMES. YEAH
ESPECIALLY DURING THE- GREAT
RECESSION WE HAD A LOT OF
CLOSURES WE SAW INCREASING
CONSOLIDATION RENTAL OWNERSHIP.
AND LARGE CORPORATIONS. WHICH
LEADS ARE GOOD IF ARE YOURS
LEADING. SENATE CONTEST. HERE'S
SO UNLESS WE HAVE A STRONG
NATIONAL PROTECTIONS IN
CALIFORNIA. ALL RIGHT THESE
MEDIATORS SIGNIFICANTLY
INCREASES ON HOUSING SHARE THE
EXISTING HOUSES SO WE NEED TO
DO THAT NOW BECAUSE PEOPLE ARE
BEING DISPLACED NOW. FINALLY MY
LAST FLIGHT. I'M GEORGE FIXES
AS A LONGER DISTANCE. SO WHAT
IS THERE ARE STILL TRYING TO
WOO FONG MANAGED HOUSING
OPERATORS TO OFFER THEIR
RECORDS OF SOME. LITTLE TIME TO
FINISH REALLY PROMISES LOCAL
OWNERSHIP SOMEONE WILL PROVIDE
PROPERTY TAX EXEMPTION FOR
OWNERS WHO ARE WILLING TO DO
THAT FOR A FIVE YEAR PERIOD SO.
NOT A PROBLEM SINCE IS GRANTED
TO NONPROFITS WHO WILL OPERATE
FOR A HOUSING LOAN I DON'T
WANNA LOSE SOME. FOR PROFIT
REDHOT HOUSE OPERATORS TO OFFER
HERE PARTNERS WERE RAISED LOW
MARKET LOW INCOME PEOPLE. FOR
SOMETIMES TODAY JERRY. WHAT THE
PASSWORD ALL CREATE MEDALS
PROGRAM WHAT MASSACHUSETTS
WHICH HAS BEEN VERY EFFECTIVE
US IS NINETEEN NINETY THREE.
HOUSING EXISTENCE FOR MANY
HOUSEHOLDS IN WHICH IS OPERATED
BY REGIONAL HOUSING AUTHORITIES
AND AGENCIES. AND WHAT ABOUT
THE WALTERS'S WE NEED TO
PROVIDE A RIGHT OF FIRST
REFUSAL ON SALE FOR ANY RENTAL
HOUSING THAT SOLD ON THE MARKET
ALLOWING TENANTS NONPROFIT AS
FOLLOWS FIRST CRACK AT BUYING
THOSE UNITS ADAM LOW MARKET
PRICE. AND KEEP IN THE YEARS TO
FORMAL. TO WHILE ABOUT CAPITAL
GAINS ROLE TO SAY FOR OWNERS
WHOSE HIS SOUL OWNERS REALLY
CAPTURED SHARE OF THE NATIONAL
HEARING BEFORE HOUSING SO
CALLED DOLLARS. WE CAPTURE THE
REASONS HOUSING RISK BURKE. OF
TO MARKET RENSSELAER
CONDOMINIUM. WE GET RESERVE A
WHOLE LOT MOBILE HOME PARKS
EDITOR. AT EIGHT HUNDRED EIGHT.
EIGHT NINE THIS IS HARD. WHAT
ELSE WAS- SO CONTROL. MY ALSO
NEED FOR BILLION ONE POINT
THREE BILLION A YEAR THIS IF
THEY WANT TO CONTROL IS IMPOSED
ACROSS THE STATE. AND IT IS
REALLY. REALLY OUR LOW INCOME
TENANTS SO. FINALLY JUST SHOT
OUT TO RURAL HOUSING BECAUSE
THAT'S WHERE WE WORK- IT GOES
TO BILL NOT RATED FOR HOUSING
NO MATTER WHERE IT IS IT TAKES
MANY MANY PARTIES TO DO THAT
AND YOU KNOW WORKING WITH THE
STATE LEGISLATURE HOPEFULLY WE
CAN GRAYSON PART NEXT YEAR AND
CON HERE'S WHAT WE CAN NORALLY
SANDERS SOCIAL HOUSING SECTOR
AND THE SUPPLIERS SOCIALLY
RENTED AND ON HOUSING IN
CALIFORNIA. THANK. YOU FOR YOUR
pWINNER THAT WAS INCREDIBLY
INFORMATIVE AND WE DEEPLY
APPRECIATED. I WILL BE HEARING
FROM OUR NEXT PANELIST
PROFESSOR PROFESSOR KEOGH IT'S-
WHO WILL PRESENT AS WELL AND
THEN WE WILL OPEN UP FOR Q. NA-
FROM THE ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S. A
PROFESSOR. RIGHT THANK YOU VERY
MUCH I WILL I WILL NEED TO
SHARE MY SCREEN AS WELL.
I HOPE
YOU'RE SEEING THE- THE SLIDE ON
THE SCREEN. IS THAT OKAY. WE AT
WE ARE NOT. VERA OKAY RIGHT.
TWENTY MINUTES. RIGHT. OKAY ALL
RIGHT THANK YOU VERY MUCH
ASSEMBLY MEMBER ENSURE WICKS
AND TO THE OTHER SENATE
MEMBERS- IN ATTENDANCE- RASO
VERY BROADLY ABOUT THE- THE
AFFORDABLE HOUSING APPROACH- IN
THE UNITED STATES HONEST ZERO
IN ON PUBLIC HOUSING- THAT-
PORTION OF OUR POLICY AFTER DAD
HE MOST RESEMBLES- THE SOCIAL
HOUSING MODEL IN A LOT OF OTHER
IN A LOT OF OTHER COUNTRIES-
AND- OF THE HEREBY KNOW. THAT A
PUBLIC HOUSING IN THE UNITED
STATES REALLY REFLECTS TO
DIFFERENT- TRADITIONS OF REFORM
AND THOUGHT- THE FIRST ONE.
HAVING TO DO WITH- THE MODERN
HOUSING MOVEMENT IN WHAT'S
CALLED A MODERN HOUSING
MOVEMENT OF THE EARLY AND MID
TWENTIETH CENTURY. AND THIS WAS
INSPIRED BY SOCIAL HOUSING
IDEAS IN IN EUROPE AND REALLY
REVOLVES AROUND THE NOTION OF.
HOUSING IS A MUNICIPAL SERVICE.
HOUSING THAT WOULD BE PROVIDED
BY THE GOVERNMENT- TO SERVICE A
BROAD CROSS SECTION OF
RESIDENTS- OF WOMEN WORKING
WELL PAST. THREE IN GLASS
FAMILIES DID NOT HAVE READY
ACCESS TO DECENT AND SAFE AND
AFFORDABLE HOUSING- SO THIS IS
NOT REALLY HOUSING TO FIX. ANY
PARTICULAR- MARKET FAILURE- BUT
RATHER THE IDEA THAT- WAS
MOTIVATED BY THE FACT THAT
HOUSING WAS SEEN AS AN
APPROPRIATE SERVICE THAT SHOULD
BE PROVIDED BY BY GOVERNMENT.
AND SO TEN SELECTION-
GUIDELINES REALLY FAVORED
EMPLOYED FAMILIES AND FAVORED
IN TACT- MANLY'S ARRESTS WERE
SET A RELATIVELY HIGH- FOR WHAT
WE CONSIDER TO BE A SOCIAL
HOUSING- THEY WERE SET ALSO TO
FULLY COVER THE OPERATING
EXPENSES OF THE HOUSING AT THE
BEGINNING- IT IN FACT. THE IDEA
WAS THAT WRESTLING WOULD NOT
ONLY COVER OPERATING EXPENSES
BUT WOULD ALSO RETIRE A PORTION
OF THE CONSTRUCTION THAT. AND
ALSO ALLOW THE HOUSING
AUTHORITIES TO PAY A IN LIEU OF
TAXES NEED TO LOCAL GOVERNMENTS
BECAUSE THIS WAS GOVERNMENT
OWNED PROPERTY I WAS EXEMPT
FROM PROPERTY TAXES SO AGAIN
THE NOTION WAS THAT THIS WAS
FULLY SELF SUFFICIENT AND-
HOUSING. AND THAT THE REST THAT
WOULD BE GENERATED FROM THE
SIZING WE'RE GOING TO BE
SUFFICIENT TO OPERATE. IN THAT
MANNER. AND SO. THE IDEA WAS
THAT THIS WOULD BE MIXED INCOME
HOUSING AND WILL NOT BE-
CONCENTRATED- IT HAPPENS OF
VERY LOW INCOME ETCETERA SO-
THE OTHER NOTION BEHIND MODERN
HOUSING IS THAT THIS HOUSING
WAS SEEN AS A WAY OF DEVELOPING
STRONG COMMUNITIES THERE WAS AN
AWARENESS. OF HOUSING'S ROLE IN
LARGER COMMUNITY DYNAMICS AND-
THE IDEA IS VERY MODERN HOUSING
IS THAT YOU WERE BUILDING A
STABLE ENVIRONMENT FOR- FOR
MIDDLE CLASS AND WORKING CLASS
FAMILIES AND THAT THIS WAS THE
WAY THAT THE GOVERNMENT SHOULD
DO THAT. THIS IS- INCOME TO THE
SECONDS. TRADITION OF- PUBLIC
HOUSING WE SAW REALLY
GOVERNMENT INTERVENTION HOUSING
MORE AS A AS A SOCIAL SERVICE
RATHER THAN A MUNICIPAL
SERVICES MORE BROADLY THAT THE
IDEA WAS HERE THAT WITH THE
HOUSING SHOULD BE TARGETED TO
THE NEEDIEST FAMILIES HI THIS
GREW OUT OF THE SETTLEMENT
HOUSE MOVEMENT OF THE EARLY
TWENTIETH CENTURY THE NOTION.
THAT WE NEEDED TO DO ABOUT-
PHILANTHROPIC MONEY BUT ALSO
GOVERNMENT MONEY- ITERATION OF
ASSISTING THE NEW YEAR'S- AMONG
US AND THIS WAS REALLY I A
CORRECTIVE. FOR MARKETERS
FAILURE AND REALLY ANYMORE
TARGETED APPLICATION OF THE
IDEA OF. HOUSING ASSISTANCE.
AND THIS WAS THE I THINK TO FAN.
WHO WERE SIMPLY NOT AT ALL BY
THE FEDERAL EVERYBODY- PRIVATE
SECTOR. AND SO THAT WAS THE
THAT WAS THE- THE OTHER A
TRADITION BEHIND- PUBLIC
HOUSING AND THESE I THINK IT
SHOULD BE NOTED OUR IDEAL
TYPES- AND- THE FACT OF THE
MATTER IS THAT PUBLIC HOUSING
BECAME A NEXT OF BOTH OF THESE
APPROACHES ACTUAL PUBLIC
HOUSING WAS- EACH YEAR THIS
YEAR THE BALANCE BETWEEN THESE
TWO MODELS. HAS NEVER TRULY
BEEN RESOLVED IN FACT I THINK
IT'S ACCURATE TO SAY THAT THE
PROGRAM IN THE UNITED STATES
HAS LONG BACK AND FORTH- FROM
ALL THESE IDEAS- ONE TO THE
OTHER- ADDED EARLY PROGRAM OF
PUBLIC HOUSING LEAN. TOWARD THE
EUROPEAN SOCIAL HOUSING MODEL
IT LEANED TOWARD THE MODERN
HOUSING- IDEAS- IN THAT A LOT
OF THE TENANT SELECTION WAS.
ORIENTED TOWARDS WORKING
FAMILIES INTACT. NUCLEAR
FAMILIES- BUT AT THE SAME TIME
TO THE PROGRAM TIED TO. POLICY
OBJECTIVES RELATED TO THE SLUM
CLEARANCE. AND IT WAS FROM THE
BEGINNING- SUPPOSED TO RE HOUSE
MANY OF THE FAMILIES THAT WERE
DISPLACED BY SLUM CLEARANCE IN
THE AND FORTIES- AND SO- THERE
WAS ELEMENT IN THE DESIGN OF
THE PROGRAM AND ACTED IN THE
WAY IT WAS OPERATED IN THE
EARLY YEARS HE DID NOT-
FUNCTION IN THAT MATTER.THAT
IS VERY FEW OF THE FAMILIES
THAT WERE DISPLACED BY SLUM
CLEARANCE WERE RE HOUSED IN
THAT FIRST GENERATION OF PUBLIC
HOUSING. BY FIRST GENERATION OF
PUBLIC HOUSING AND TALKING
ABOUT THE HOUSING THAT WAS
BUILT FROM THE- MID THIRTIES
INTO THE. EARLY NINETEEN
FIFTIES- STILL MOST OF THAT
HOUSING DID- WAS NOT- HE
INHABITED BY THOSE WHO HAVE
BEEN DISPLACED BY SLUM
CLEARANCE. EVEN THOUGH- THE
PROGRAM IS DESIGNED TO DO THAT.
THE IMPORTANT ELEMENT THOUGH OF
THE SLUM CLEARANCE CONNECTION
IS THAT A LITTLE A LARGE
PERCENTAGE OF PUBLIC HOUSING-
IN THE MID PART OF THE
TWENTIETH CENTURY WAS PLACED IN
CENTRAL NEIGHBORHOODS OF LARGER
CITIES. AWARE SLUM CLEARANCE
WAS TAKING PLACE AND THIS
BECOMES A MATTER OF TREMENDOUS
IMPORTANCE WHEN WE THINK ABOUT
THE EVOLUTION OF PUBLIC
HOUSING- IN THE UNITED STATES
BECAUSE THESE. DEVELOPMENTS
WERE SET RIGHT IN THE MIDDLE OF
COMMUNITIES- THAT WERE.
EXPERIENCING WHITE FLIGHT AND
PRIVATE SECTOR DISINVESTMENT
AND I CONTINUE TO EXPERIENCE IN
SENATE IN A WAR- YEARS IF NOT
DECADES AFTER THE DEVELOPMENT
OF THE PUBLIC HOUSING ITSELF.
SO THIS IS WHAT IT IS IMPORTANT
NOTING ABOUT HIS FIRST
GENERATION OF PUBLIC HOUSING IS
BEING SLIGHTLY DIFFERENT FROM
WHAT- INSTITUTED IN THE FIFTIES
THE SIXTIES AND SEVENTIES- IN
IN CONSTRUCTION AND DESIGN IT
WAS REALLY QUITE. DIFFERENT
FROM- FROM WHAT PREVAILED IN
THE FIFTIES AND SIXTIES-
ANTENNA SELECTION- I THINK THAT
YOU CAN LOOK AT BUILDINGS- OF
BUILT IN THE THIRTIES IN THE
EARLY FORTIES THAT WERE REALLY
QUITE WELL BUILT. OF THAT WERE
BUILT TO LAST FOR SEVENTY YEARS
AND THAT HAVE ALL REALLY FROM A
STRUCTURAL STANDPOINT- MET THAT
OBJECTIVE- I THINK YOU CAN
ALSO- POINT TO THE FIRST TWENTY
TWENTY FIVE YEARS OF PUBLIC
HOUSING AS YEARS WHERE THE
FISCAL MODEL. ACTUALLY WORK
WHICH IS TO SAY THAT THE RENTS
IN THOSE DEVELOPMENTS WERE
SUFFICIENT TO COVER OPERATING
EXPENSES THEY DID BEGAN TO
RETIRE SOME OF THEIR DADS-
RELATED TO CONSTRUCTION L. THEY
DID. GO IN THE- BOARDS IN LIEU
OF FEES TO LOCAL GOVERNMENT- TO
COVER FOR THE LOSS OF. PROPERTY
TAXES SO- SO THIS IS A MODEL
THAT ACTUALLY WORKED AND IT
WORKED FOR A COUPLE OF DECADES-
BUT IT DIDN'T WORK FOREVER- AND
IN FACT BY THE NINETEEN FIFTIES
INTO THE NINETEEN SIXTIES. HE
OF THE MODEL BEGAN TO- REALLY-
FALL APART AND IT IT FELL APART
FOR A NUMBER OF DIFFERENT
REASONS- BUT- THINK ABOUT WHAT
WAS HAPPENING IN THE IN THE
FIFTIES AND SIXTIES THE UNITED
STATES- AND URBAN AREAS WERE
EXPERIENCING. SOME SIGNIFICANT
POST WAR RECOVERY JOBS WERE
BEING ADDED TO THE ECONOMY- WE
WERE EXPANDING HOMEOWNERSHIP
THROUGH SOME OF THE PROGRAMS
THAT ROB COVERED. EARLIER IN
HIS PRESENTATION- WE SAW
SIGNIFICANT. PATTERNS OF BUT
SHARE AFTER OUR CENTRAL CITIES
IN A SORT OF A- AREAS- AND IT
IS IMPORTANT THAT. ALL OF WHAT
I JUST SPOKE ABOUT THE JOBS AND
JOB AVAILABILITY THE NEW
HOMEOWNERSHIP OPPORTUNITIES AND
SUBURBANIZATION. WORD DYNAMICS
THAT WERE OPERATING WITHIN AN
ACE A SYSTEM OF. SYSTEMIC
DISCRIMINATION AND RACISM
AGAINST PEOPLE OF COLOR SO
THESE ARE OPPORTUNITIES BY AND
LARGE THAT WERE BEING MADE
AVAILABLE TO WHITE FAMILIES-
AND PREDOMINANTLY ONLY LIKE
FAMILIES. AND SO WE TALK ABOUT-
YEAH ALLEN HAS ACTUALLY THE
AVERAGE PROGRAMS THAT ROB
TALKING ABOUT WE'RE TALKING
ABOUT. MOST OF THOSE-
BENEFICIARIES BEING WHITE
FAMILIES SO WHY FAMILIES ARE
MOVING OUT OF PUBLIC HOUSING IN
LARGE NUMBERS IN THE FIFTIES TO
TAKE ADVANTAGE OF THESE NEW
HOUSING OPPORTUNITIES- BUT
BLACK FAMILIES I IS VERY
FAMILIES DO NOT HAVE THE SAME
OPPORTUNITIES AND IN FACT FOR
THOSE FAMILIES. PUBLIC HOUSING
WAS THE BEST A HOUSING OPTIONS
AVAILABLE TO THEM AND SO WE SAW
A SIGNIFICANT CHANGE IN THE
DEMOGRAPHICS OF PUBLIC HOUSING
IN THE NINETEEN FIFTIES TO THE
POINT WHERE BY THE END OF THE
NINETEEN FIFTIES ALL THE
HOUSING WAS- WAS. VERY RACIALLY
IDENTIFIED- AND ONE THING SAID
HAD WILL- AND THERE'S I AND
THEY WERE TAKING ADVANTAGE OF
COMMERCE. OF THE OTHER DYNAMICS
THAT WERE TAKING PLACE AT THIS
TIME BECAUSE OF THE
DEMOGRAPHICS OF POVERTY WAS
CHANGING IN THE UNITED STATES-
WE SAW. A LARGE EXPANSION IN-
IN THE FEMINIZATION OF POVERTY-
AND ALSO. THE- BE. PHENOMENON
ARE INTERGENERATIONAL POVERTY
WHAT- WHAT- WHAT ROB CALLED-
MORE MORE OR LESS PERMANENT OR-
POVERTY AND THIS IS THE BODILY
GAMES SO SHADED WITH THE
RESIDENTS OF PUBLIC HOUSING
DURING THIS PERIOD OF TIME. AS
OPPOSED TO THAT TEMPORARY
MIDDLE CLASS SORT OF MERGING-
THAT WAS ASSOCIATED WITH A
PUBLIC HOUSING RESIDENTS IN THE
THIRTIES AND FORTIES THAT WAS
PRIMARILY A RESULT OF THE-
GREAT DEPRESSION SERVICE I
SHOULD HAVE TO ENTER
GENERATIONALLY AND RACIALLY
DISPARATE. ALREADY PATTERNS-
YOU LAYER ON TOP OF THIS THE
FACT THAT CONGRESS WAS
DIRECTING LOCAL HOUSING
AUTHORITIES TO TARGET THEIR
HOUSING TOWARDS THE NEEDIEST-
HAD THIS VERY SAME TIME AND SO
YOU HAD THESE DIRECTIVES ON
TENANTS SELECTION SO THIS IS
THAT PERIOD OF TIME WE SAW THE
DECLINE OF PUBLIC HOUSING IN
RATHER DRAMATIC AWAY- WHICH-
WAS REFLECTED IN IN PUBLIC
DISCOURSE ABOUT THE. PUBLIC
HOUSING RISK TIME. ENTER A AND
OF HOUSING FROM THE NINETEEN
NINETIES ON OUR WHICH. YES
AGAIN OUR OUR NOTION OF PUBLIC
HOUSING IN THE UNITED STATES WE
ADDED ABOLISHED THOUSANDS OF
UNITS OF PUBLIC HOUSING WE
REPLACE THEM WITH NEW- INCOME
MIXED PUBLIC HOUSING.
DEVELOPMENT SAID INCORPORATED
PUBLIC HOUSING LOAN HOUSING TAX
CREDIT HOUSING BUT ALSO MARKET
RATE HOUSING- SOMETIMES THERE'S
EVEN A TENURE NEXT YOU WOULD
HAVE A HOMEOWNERSHIP AS PART OF
THESE OLD SIX PROJECTS AGAIN.
THE R. NINETEEN NINETY EIGHT.
AS A MEMBER OF- DIRECTED
HOUSING. TO CREATE A GREATER
INCOME MAX IT LIMITED THE
NUMBER AND PERCENTAGES OF
UNISEX COULD BE OFFERED TO
TENANTS WHO HAD VERY- AN
EXTREMELY LOW INCOMES. AND FOR
THE FIRST TIME IN A GENERATION
OR SO- DIRECTED HOUSING
AUTHORITY TO TARGET THE- THE
WORKING POOR- AND- AND THOSE
WITH- WITH CITY INCOMES.
ELLEN'S AN SO I THINK THAT'S
THE ERA WE'RE IN QUITE A WE'RE
IN RIGHT NOW I THINK THAT THIS
OVERALL- TRAJECTORY OF PUBLIC
HOUSING. REALLY NEED. REALLY IS
IT CHALLENGES IS TO SCORE THAT
THAT PUBLIC HOUSING WAS A
FAILURE OR PUBLIC HOUSING- IT
IS A DISASTER IN SOME IN SOME
WAYS I WILL SAY THAT MOST
PUBLIC HOUSING IN MOST PLACES
IN THE UNITED STATES ACTUALLY
WORKED PRETTY WELL AND
CONTINUES TO WORK PRETTY WELL.
AND THAT IS ESPECIALLY THE CASE
IN SMALL AND MID SIZED CITIES
AND IN NON METROPOLITAN AREAS
BUT EVEN IN LARGER CITIES- I
THINK YOU CAN FIND EXAMPLES OF
PUBLIC HOUSING WORKS QUITE
WELL. WHEN THE WHEN THE FEDERAL
GOVERNMENT CREATED A COMMISSION
TO IDENTIFY WHAT IT CALLED THE
MOST SEVERELY DISTRESSED PUBLIC
HOUSING THEY IDENTIFIED EIGHTY
SIX THOUSAND UNITS NATIONWIDE
WELL THAT'S A LOT OF UNITS. BUT
IT IS STILL- ONLY 6% OF THE
PUBLIC HOUSING STOCK IN THE
COUNTRY AT THAT TIME WHICH WAS
ABOUT ONE POINT THREE MILLION
WE TORN DOWN ALMOST A QUARTER
OF A MILLION OF THOSE AND SO
THE PUBLIC HOUSING STOCK IS A
LITTLE OVER ONE MILLION AT THIS
TIME BUT I DO THINK IT'S ARE WE
CAN. REALLY THINK ABOUT PUBLIC
HOUSING- HAS A MIXTURE OF VERY
LARGE AND WELL PUBLICIZED.
FAILURES BUT- I AM A- EIGHT OF
HOUSING AND- SERVED FOR- PRETTY
WELL AND I THINK CONTINUE TALK
THE LESS. I'M GOING TO THROUGH
SOME. OF PUBLIC HOUSING THAT
WAS THAT WERE BUILT- A COUPLE
OF GENERATIONS AGO- THAT REALLY
HAVEN'T TOURED THAT ARE
EXAMPLES OF WELL BUILT- WELL
OPERATED PUBLIC HOUSING THERE
ARE LASTING EXAMPLES OF.
ARCHITECTURE AND IN SOME CASES
URBAN DESIGN- THAT ALLOW THOSE
DEVELOPMENTS TO FIT INTO THE
COMMUNITIES IN WHICH THEY ARE
LOCATED. I KNEW THAT I WANTED
TO LEAVE. WITH THESE. DIFFERENT
LESSONS FROM PUBLIC PUBLIC
HOUSING AND THAT'S A
CONSTRUCTION AND FINANCING AND
MANAGEMENT REALLY MATTER A
GREAT DEAL THERE'S NOTHING
INHERENT IN THE PUBLIC HOUSING
MODEL. THAT SUGGESTS THAT IS-
AND IT WON'T WORK- ADDED BACK
WE NEED TO THINK ABOUT HOW WE
CONSTRUCT IT- THEY WERE
DRAMATIC PRESSURES TO REDUCE
CONSTRUCTION COSTS. I IN
NINETEEN FIFTIES THAT LED TO
CHEAT AND INADEQUATE
CONSTRUCTION I THINK WE NEED TO
LEARN THAT LESSON THINK ABOUT
THOSE BUILDINGS THAT WERE BUILT
IN THE THIRTIES AND FORTIES
THAT HAVE STANDARDS. THAT
INSTEAD OF THE LAST- THE
LESSONS OF TIME- I THINK HE.
DOES CONSTRUCTION- PRESSURE
COST PRESSURE LED TO DESIGNS.
THAT WE'RE NOT- WELL- REACTOR
TO. BY RESIDENTS. ARE IN A TO-
THE PREMATURE. ON OF THOSE YOU
KNOW STEM CELLS AND LEAD TO AN
ALIENATING LIVING ENVIRONMENT
PREMATURE AGING OF THOSE OF
THOSE UNITS FINANCING MATTERS A
GREAT DEAL HOW RENTS ARE SET.
HOW MAY I HELP YOU INCOMES ARE
MIXED WITH INTELLIGENCE-
WHETHER OPERATING SUBSIDIES ARE
MADE AVAILABLE. TO HOUSING
AUTHORITIES. EUNICE THIS IS A
OF IT FINE. YOU KNOW IT'S NOT
IN PROFIT DEVELOPERS EIGHT TO
TWELVE DIFFERENT FINANCING
OPTIONS TODAY TO BUILD
AFFORDABLE HOUSING AND THAT'S
JUST VERY TIME CONSUMING- AND
LABOR INTENSIVE TO PRODUCE
HOUSING WE CAN DO THAT MORE
SIMPLY AND- AND WE DID THAT
MORE SIMPLY DURING THE PUBLIC
HOUSING- ERRO- I THINK IT IS
IMPORTANT TO REMEMBER. HAVING
GOALS OF- STATEWIDE AND
MUNICIPAL- PUBLIC HOUSING
PROGRAMS THAT EXISTED IN IN NEW
YORK- AND ENVIRONMENT
MANAGEMENT- IS IMPORTANT AS
WELL- WE NEED TO THE BIGGEST
DISASTERS OF THE PUBLIC HOUSING
WERE RELATED TO POOR
MANAGEMENT- AND DISINVESTMENT
BY THE PUBLIC SECTOR- AND
THAT'S NOT REALLY AN HEARINGS-
ELEMENTS OF THE- PROGRAM AS
WELL- AND- AND THAT WE CAN LOOK
AT PUBLIC HOUSING THAT REALLY
FITS IN QUITE WELL- IT IS
ENVIRONMENT IT DOESN'T LOOK
LIKE WHAT WE CONSIDER TO BE A
PROTOTYPICAL. PUBLIC HOUSING
THERE NEED NOT BE STIGMATIZED
BY ITS- LAYS APPEARANCE BUT I
CAN'T BE AN ATTRIBUTE- TO THE
COMMUNITIES IN WHICH- IS
LOCATED AND SO I WILL- I WILL
LEAVE IT AT THAT AND ALLOW. FOR
FOR QUESTION AND. ANSWER- FROM
THE- YOU. YOUR PAP THE YEAH
THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR WE'VE-
OF THIS AND I THINK
UNDERSTANDING THE HISTORICAL
NATURE OF WHERE WE HAVE COME IS
IMPORTANT TO THINK ABOUT WHAT
POLICY LEVERS WE WANT TO DO TO
MOVE FORWARD TO- I THINK I
CONTINUE TO HONOR THE GOOD
THINGS THAT HAVE WORKS WITH OUR
PUBLIC HOUSING EXPERIMENTS BUT
THEN ADDRESS THE THINGS THAT
HAVEN'T WORKED AND CREATE- MORE
LIVABLE PLACES FOR- OUR
COMMUNITY MEMBERS THAT NEEDED-
I WOULD ASK ONE QUESTION AND
KICK IT OFF TO MY COLLEAGUES.
ON THE FIRST QUESTION I LOVE AT
ASK DOCTOR WIENER IS- ARE THERE
OTHER STATES WITHIN THE UNITED
STATES THAT HAVE SOCIAL HOUSING
MODELS THAT WE CAN LEARN FROM
AND HOW ARE THEY FUNDED. YOU
KNOW IN ANYWAYS CALIFORNIA IS
EVEN GREATER- YOUR HAND TERMS
OF A FINANCING SOURCES THAT WE
USE. WE HAVE A VERY VITAL. AND
STRONG BETTER. SOCIAL HOUSING
SECTOR OF NONPROFIT GROUPS THAT
ARE REALLY. VERY COMPETENCE.
HANDJOB I THINK THE CITY CLOSES
TO THE EUROPEAN MODEL IN YOUR
CITY AND- I'M SURE IF YOU ARE
TALK ABOUT THAT YOU WORKING IN
NEW YORK FOR AWHILE- BUT I
WOULD SAY GENERALLY OF. YOUR
VERY FEW PLACES IN THIS COUNTRY
THAT HAS SUCH A LARGE AND
SOPHISTICATED. NONPROFIT
HOUSING SECTOR AS WE DO IN
CALIFORNIA- AND WE ALSO HAVE
THE CITY FOR A VERY INNOVATIVE
FINANCE MECHANISMS LIKE CAP AND
TRADE FUNDS AND HE RECORDED
AGENCY. AYE BILLIONAIRE'S HOUSE
SO WE- TRYING TO USE SUPPORT
THE PRODUCTION OF THE FOR
HOUSING AND THE SORT OF HUGS.
PERHAPS ONCE WHEN I WAS AROUND
WELL. THANK YOU NOW TURN OVER
MY CALL TO SOMEONE EARLY. I
FIRST WANT TO DIRECT MY I HAVE
TO GO THE FIRST HUNDRED
QUESTION TO DOCTOR WIENER AND
FOR SOMEONE TO SAY- IT'S GOOD
TO SEE YOU ACTUALLY TOOK A
CLASS IN TWENTY SEVENTEEN WHEN
I WAS IN C. DAVIS. AND THIS IS
WHEN I SO I REMEMBER GOING TO
THE ENTIRE COURSE AND YOU
TEACHING US ABOUT THE HISTORY
OF PUBLIC HOUSING AND GOING TO
THE EXAMPLES IN DAVIS I THINK
IT'S GO TO THE TRIPS TO SPAIN
THAT YEAR I DON'T THINK WE HAVE
THAT. BUT I REALLY HAVE TO CUT
THE MEMORY YOU FOR LIKE REALLY
TEACHING AND ALL THESE THINGS
THE SEWING GROUP IN THE SUBURBS
I HAD LIKE NO REAL
UNDERSTANDING OF THE VAST THIS
REALLY EXISTS AND I THINK A LOT
OF THAT LEARNING I BROUGHT TO
THE STATE ASSEMBLY NOW SONY
THANK YOU PERSON WITH THAT.
THANK YOU FOR DOING THAT ARE
DOING. AND LIKE MY- FORM. THANK
YOU I'M GLAD YOU REVEREND- BUT
MY QUESTION REALLY IS AND FOR
THE ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S YOU TO
REALLY FOR US TO LEARN OR TO
THINK ABOUT IS WHEN WE'RE
CRAFTING SOCIAL HOUSING POLICY
FOR CALIFORNIA WHAT WOULD YOU
SAY ARE THE TOP TWO POLICY
PITFALLS WE SHOULD AVOID
LEARNING FROM THE HISTORY OF
PUBLIC HOUSING. WELL I THINK
THAT- IT KATHLEEN THOSE
CORRECTLY- BUILDING WITH CAROLS.
BUILDING WELL DESIGNED HOUSING
THAT DOES NOT FEEL
INSTITUTIONAL. LAKE AREA UNLIKE
FACTORY- REALLY HOUSING THAT IS
DESIGNED TO LAST WITH GOOD
INTENTIONS. WE A LOT OF
RESIDENT INVOLVEMENT AND-
MANAGEMENT AND OPERATIONAL
DECISIONS GOOD LOCATION. OKAY
HOUSING PROGRAM WE SAW THAT IT
WAS A PREMIUM PLACED ON
BUILDING WHICH GENERAL'S
LOCATIONS OF YOURS ARE RURAL
ADDRESS ISOLATED FROM- YOUR
MIGRANT NEIGHBORHOODS AND
SERVICES TRANSIT PARTS SEVERAL.
SO MODEL TODAY'S BUILD.
ASSISTED HOUSING WHICH IS NOT
PUBLIC PRIVATELY OWNED OFTHE
SENATE SIZE HAS LEARNED A LOT
FROM THOSE LESSONS LESSONS THAT
ACCRUED I GO AND LESSONS.
OTHERS AND IS DESIGNED IS STILL
BUILT WITH MATERIALS THAT ARE
DESIGNED LAST YEAR DURRELL
THEIR ENERGY EFFICIENT- WATER-
AND THEY ARE REALLY OF WARM
FRIENDLY PLACES THAT OUR
SERVICE IS RICH. THOSE LESSONS
YOU CAN GO TO WAY FOR SOME OF
THE FAILURES. OF AUGUST PROGRAM.
THANK YOU. AND LET S. SUNBURST
BONTA. IT THANK YOU AT DR GETS
AT I REALLY APPRECIATE THAT YOU
ACTUALLY OUTLINED ARE
HIGHLIGHTED AGAIN AT THE FACTOR
OF OCATION- AND THE ATTENDANT
ISOLATION AND THAT- CAME FROM
MANY PUBLIC HOUSING
DEVELOPMENTSAS BEING A
CRITICAL- I THINK AT POTENTIAL
FACT A FACTOR IN THE FAILURE OF
PUBLIC HOUSING SALE I
UNDERSTAND CONSTRUCTION
FINANCING AND MANAGEMENT TO BE
PRETTY CRITICAL BUT I VERY MUCH
APPRECIATED. LOCATION BEING
RAISED BECAUSE THAT FOR ME WAS
ONE OF THE CRITICAL ISSUES THAT
I SAW FOR MANY LOW INCOME
COMMUNITIES IN POOR COMMUNITIES
WHO ARE JUST ISOLATED FROM
THEIR CITIES FROM SERVICES AND
ARE QUITE FRANKLY FROM BEING A
PART OF THE COMMUNITY FABRIC I
DIDN'T WANT TO JUST HAVE- I
THINK DOCTOR WIENER A FOCUS A
LITTLE BIT ON THE SOME OF THAT
SHORT TERM FIXES THAT YOU
IDENTIFIED SPECIFICALLY OR THE
LONG TERM FIXES THAT YOU
IDENTIFIED. SPECIFICALLY
FOCUSING ON THAT RIGHT OF FIRST
REFUSAL FOR DIFFERENT- FOR
DIFFERENT GROUPS AS AN
OPPORTUNITY I THINK WE COULD
POTENTIALLY EXPLORE- AS AS
SOCIAL HOUSING COMPONENTS OF
JUST MORE THAT MORE INFORMATION
ABOUT THAT PLACE SURE WE ARE CO
SPONSORED A BILL IN TWENTY
NINETEEN WITH THE CALIFORNIA
HOUSING PARTNERSHIP. THAT WILL
PROVIDE EACH- APPLE GAINES
BANDAGES FOR OWNERS OF.
DIFFERENT KINDS OF. RENTAL
HOUSING. AS WELL MOBILE WHERE
TO SELL THEIR PROPERTY TO
SOCIAL. BUYERS AND OWNERS.
NAMELY TO RESIDENTS TO NOT
RIGHT NOT A PROBLEM IS TO
FOLLOW HOUSING AGENCIES. OF S.
GREAT WAY TO TRY TO DEVISE
EXISTING ORDERS. TO OFF LOAD
THEIR PROPERTY SAID THEY'RE
PLANNING TO GET OUT OF INSTEAD
OF SELLING ON THE PRIVATE
MARKET AT MARKET PRICE- SO IT'S
TO SORTOF HOUSING. PROVIDERS
AND GET A OF CAPITAL GAINS.
THEN PERHAPS A TAX CREDIT. AND
FRAUDULENT OF THE- THIS WAY WE
SHOULD BE GOOD BECAUSE- WE
CAN'T BUILD ENOUGH YOU IN THE
RIGHT PLACES. I PRICE POINTS-
QUICKLY ENOUGH TO HOUSE ALL THE
ALL THE PEOPLE WHO ARE OF THE
AGE SHOULD BE DISPLACED
TOMORROW. WE SEE THAT OF
COURSE. WE SEEM DETERMINED
RECESSION. TIMES AS WELL. WE
NEED A VERY PROACTIVE TRYING TO
GET THOSE PROPERTIES WERE MOST
LOW INCOME PEOPLE LIVE. THIS IS
A SOCIAL HOUSING SLEEPING ON.
SO THE RATES WOULD ALSO
OWNERSHIP. AND SO I WOULD HOPE
THAT WE COULD JUST GO SUPPORT
THIS COMING- LEGISLATIVE
SESSION FOR THAT LEGISLATION
AND SIMILAR PIECE OF
LEGISLATION. I DON'T QUESTION
ANY OTHER QUESTIONS. I REQUEST
SOME MEMBER LEE HAS WON MORE
THAN WILL WILL WRAP UP. I HAVE
A QUESTION FOR DR EDWARD GETS-
I WAS JUST CURIOUS YOU'RE
SHOWING US A LOT OF THE
DIFFERENT FACES OF PUBLIC
HOUSING THAT EXISTS IN THE
COUNTRY AND A LOT OF THOSE ARE
TWO THREE STORY STRUCTURES THAT
I THINK PRETTY MUCH WOULD. NOT
INVOKE THE IMAGE OF PUBLIC
HOUSING HAVE THIS COUNTRY OF
THE TALL BIG TOWERS IN THE PARK
THAT PROVE I GO I DON'T KNOW IF
YOU KNOW THE ANSWER THIS BUT
WHAT CONTRIBUTED TO A LOT OF
THE DESIGN OF THOSE WERE I
THINK THEY WOULD FIT PRETTY
EVEN THE SUBURBAN SETTING WOULD
CONTRIBUTE TO A LOT OF THOSE
BUILT IN THE THIRTIES FORTIES
FIFTIES THAT. ARE THIS TWO
THREE STORIES THAT ALMOST BOND
AND COMMUNITIES DO YOU HAVE A-
SENSE OF WHY THEY'RE BUILT THAT
WAY. SURE AND ACTUALLY- HI
RISES MAKE UP A SMALL
PERCENTAGE OF- OF PUBLIC
HOUSING IN THE UNITED STATES
IT'S- IT IS THE IMAGE THAT WE
HAVE OF PUBLIC HOUSING BUT-
MOST HOUSING EXISTENCE IS BUILT
IN THE EIGHTIES TWO THREE STORY
KIND OF ROLE MODELS- TYPE OF
CONFIGURATIONS- WHICH IS WHY I
WAS- THEY'RE SHOWING THOSE AS
THE EXAMPLES THAT'S REALLY THE
SORT OF PROTOTYPICAL FACED A
PUBLIC HOUSING IN MOST PLACES
IN THE UNITED STATES. AND THEY
WERE BUILT THAT WAY BECAUSE
THEY WERE THAT WAS SEEN AS A AN
APPROPRIATE SCALE- FOR THE
FAMILIES THAT WE'RE GOING TO
HAPPEN THOSE UNITS AND IT WAS
JUST SEEN AS- AS A WAY OF-
MINIMIZING BECAUSE THEY THEY
WEREN'T SINGLE FAMILY HOMES SO
THEY WERE A LITTLE LESS COSTLY.
TO PRODUCE BUT- RESPONSIVE TO
WHAT IT IS STYLE WAS THE
APPROVED USE OF THE UNIT WHICH
WAS GOING TO BE FOR FAMILY.
WITH CHILDREN THEY SHOULD TO
HIGHRISES CAME IN THE NINETEEN
FIFTIES WHEN THE FEDERAL
GOVERNMENT PUT VERY EXTREME
COST PRESSURES ON HOUSING
AUTHORITIES TO MINIMIZE
CONSTRUCTION COSTS AND SO
HOUSING AUTHORITIES COULD
MINIMIZE LAND COSTS BY BUILDING
UP INSTEAD OF BY- BUILDING IN A
MORE. PERSONAL SENSE AND THAT'S
WHY YOU SAW A LOT OF THE
HIGHRISES GETTING BILLS-
INTERNET THE INTERNET ERA AND
THOSE ARE UNFORTUNATELY THE
BUILDINGS WHERE HAVE YOU SO
SHAPE WITH THE GREATEST
FAILURES. ALL THE HOUSE. AND I
APPRECIATE YOU ELABORATING ON
THAT BECAUSE I THINK ESPECIALLY
AS WE'RE TALKING MORE ABOUT
HOUSING SOLUTIONS YOU KNOW
THERE'S A NARRATIVE OUT THERE
THAT EVERY SOLUTION OTHERS
SCARY BIG TALL GLASS OF
BRUTALIST. IN FACT I THINK EVEN
IN THE PAST WE'VE SEEN WE ARE
ABLE TO ACCOMMODATE GENTLY AND
MIX IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD SO IT'S
REALLY GLAD TO SEE THAT AND I'M
APPROACH AND I'M GLAD YOU
SHARED SOME THE STORIES HOW
PUBLIC HOUSING WAS SUCH A
SUCCESS WHEN SMALLER METRO
AREAS. AND IF YOU'RE REALLY TO
CONFRONT THE HOUSING CRISIS
THOROUGHLY IN CALIFORNIA WHERE
MOST OF IT IS SUBURBAN I THINK.
IT'S A GOOD MODELS LOOK AT
CERTAINLY. THANK YOU. WELL I
WANNA- THANK PROFESSOR GOATS
AND- DOCTOR WIENER FOR THEIR
PRESENTATION TODAY AND THEIR
KNOWLEDGE AND WE LOOK FORWARD
TO. WORKING WITH THEM IN THE
FUTURE AND WHAT MAY CALL UPON
YOUR- EXPERTISE AGAIN AS WE
THINK ABOUT WHAT KIND OF
POLICIES. WE CAN CRAFT- AND
THAT'LL CONCLUDE PANEL ONE- AND
A COUPLE THINGS BEFORE WE DIVE
INTO PANEL TO. FIRST CAN I ASK
THE MODERATOR TO PLEASE DISPLAY
ONCE MORE THE SPANISH
INTERPRETATION LINE FOR
CALLERS. ON THE LIVE STREAM TO
MAKE SURE WE CAN ACCOMMODATE.
THEM AND THEN SECONDLY. I'D
LIKE TO GO BACK AND WELCOME MY
GUEST FOR THIS HEARING- WHO IS
NOW ON THE LINE WE HAD AN ISSUE
TECH ISSUE OF GETTING HIM ON
EARLIER. HE'S ONE OF MY
CONSTITUENTS- AND HE EMBODIES
THE REASON WHY WE ARE HERE
TODAY TO DO THIS WORK. I'M HE
GOES BY SLUM JACK THAT'S HIS
STREET NAME BY WHICH HE
REQUESTED THAT WE CALL HIM. AND
HE HAS AN IMPORTANT PERSPECTIVE
THAT I WANT TO MAKE SURE IS
INCLUDED IN TODAY'S HEARING- ON
BEHALF OF THE TENS OF THOUSANDS
OF CALIFORNIANS WHO HAVE
EXPERIENCED. HOMELESSNESS AND
THEIR LIFETIME AND I KNOW OFTEN
IN THE SERIES HEARINGS WE CAN
GET- DROP DOWN INTO THE POLICY
READS WHICH IS OBVIOUSLY VERY
IMPORTANT BUT IT'S ALSO
IMPORTANT FOR US TO REMEMBER.
WHY WE ARE EXPLORING THESE
ISSUES THE PROBLEMS ARE TRYING
TO SOLVE AND THAT. THERE ARE
HUMAN BEINGSATTACHED TO THESE
POLICY OUTCOMES IN HUMANS
BEINGS EXPERIENCE EXPERIENCING-
THE NEGLECT ON THE POLICY FRONT
THAT THAT THAT WE ARE
RESPONSIBLE FOR HERE- SO WITH
THAT- SLIM JACK- THANK YOU FOR
BEING HERE. I HOPE THAT YOU'RE
ON AND- PLEASE MAKE SURE YOU
AND YOUR YOUR PHONE. HELLO
HELLO WE CAN HEAR YOU OKAY-
THANK YOU VERY MUCH AROUND HERE
WELL TO ME TODAY THE GENTLEMEN
ON THE SITUATIONS YOU HEARD
RIDICULOUS SITUATIONS LOCAL
CURRENTLY- I AM- OF YOUR
DAUGHTER LAW REQUIRES LOCAL
SURE HAVE NOW. PRIOR TO THAT-
AMBER- CHU THOUSAND. MINERS LAW
MY WATER ADAMS ANALYTICAL SHE
HE'S- A NUMBER AGENCIES
INVOLVED A MATTERS MOTIVATE-
THE. A. CLIMB WILL YOU KNOW.
RUN. JUST PRIOR TO HOME. I'M
JUST ALREADY MANAGED IN
BERKELEY OAKLAND GEN. IN TERMS
OF INCLUDING HIGHLIGHTS NOTED
BILLS ARE USUALLY WATER. HOTEL
ROOM IN PALM FEDERAL A LITTLE.
CONTACT J. ENVIRON AFFORDABLE
FOR LOW HERE AND THE- I WELL I
HERE BECAUSE I USED FOR ANY-
DISTRUST PROPOSITIONAL. FINALLY
WE OPERATE LIVE. NINETY ONE.
BACK ON TRACK AND I OPPORTUNITY
TO MEET WITH ALL NUMBER OF THE
WHEN HE- MULLIN- I ALSO WANT.
TO WORK WITH IN ALL. WAS A LOT
COMMON OF RECITAL. I DON'T
LATER WORKS BETTER- I STARTED
OFF IN LINE ONE OF OUR- HOMES
WALDRON. AS IT WAS NOT- HOMES
YOU'RE- NOT ALONE KNOW A ON.
WE'RE IN TIMES ON WE DON'T HAVE
A HOMES JOB THE ACT THE MOUTH
PEOPLE YOU HADN'T GONE. ALERTED
IT IS A HELPFUL WERE ALLOWS HE
WILL ONE AND A ERA WAS A TO GET
ON THE CONSTRUCTION THE GROUND
RIGHT- WHAT. WHAT WAS THAT YOUR
ARMS MASS LIVE. OKAY AND ONE
YOU BOB DOLE ALMOST RETURN IF
YOU CURRENTLY SHARE. LEWIS
BLACK JEANS A BLUE YOUR ISSUE
NEWLY CREDIT RATING AND THE
LITTLE SO SEN- YEAH ALMOST DONE-
ALL THE SHORTER LINE YOU THIS
WILL BEFORE. THE REQUIRED LOCAL.
MORE THAN CHURCH- THEY'LL THE
WILL PEOPLE WHO WORSHIP MOTIONS
FOR MOST PEOPLE AND THEN THE
REQUIRED MORE ON WAY I. MAYBE
ENOUGH MONEY ONE. THERE'S A ONE
KNOWN SURE I HAD. AND YOUR HELP
YOU WELL I GOT AB USED IN THE
OR YEAH SO IT IS NOT THE TIME
OF INQUIRER. OF ON CHANNEL.
NUMBER. THREE ONE- LAW WE
ROUNDELS- THEY WERE USING CHILD
NEVER PROVIDING US ALL THE
TRANSFUSION NOW WE COULD HAVE A
LITTLE. ON THE- BUT OUR YOU
GONNA GET A IT RIGHT NOW THE
REGIONAL TURN HERE'S LOCAL
WHICH MEANS IT'LL TO THE OLD
WAYS. MAGDHABA LOL. NOW THE
IMAGINE WILL HAVE BY ON THE
STREET LOVE CARE CHECK- WELL.
THAT I HAD. OKAY COULD WRAP UP
IN THE NECK MINUTE- ON A
REGULAR THE PAST YEAR. THE AND
I'M SHOWING. DRUGS OF ALL ONE
HUNDRED YEARS WE CAN WE ARE
TRONG MODERATE AREN'T WILLING
BULGING ON. THERE NOW-
RESPONSES WAGE PEOPLE ISSUE
BACKGROUND WHERE IS NOT WORKING
MONOLOGUE TRAUMA ONE TO SHARE
YOUR OWN. SO THAT'S DOT. IRAN
TO GIVE YOU IS NOT OF OFFICERS
AND AGENTS THE DEVOTED TO USE
IN. IS. ONE BUT I WANT TO YOU
FOR TEST HERE THANK YOU FOR
PUTTING A HUMAN FACE TO THE
POLICIES THAT WE ARE DISCUSSING
I THINK YOU'VE HIGHLIGHTED SOME
IMPORTANT CRITICAL THINGS THE
IDEA OF MANAGEMENT BEING KEY I
THINK IT'S COME UP A COUPLE
TIMES NOW AND WE'RE CERTAINLY
HAPPY TO SEE YOU HOUSE- AND WE
ARE COMMITTED TO ENSURING THAT
THE FOLKS SUCH AS YOURSELF
CONTINUE TO BE. UP TO HAVE
HOUSING SECURITY SO THANK YOU
VERY MUCH FOR YOUR PERSONAL
TESTIMONY STATES IT'S
INCREDIBLY IMPORTANT TO THIS
HEARING. THANK YOU N. ONE AT
MOVE ON NOW TO OUR SECOND PANEL
WHICH IS TO DISCUSS EXISTING
MODELS- AND LESSONS LEARNED AND
WE'RE GONNA BE GETTING SOME
INTERNATIONAL PERSPECTIVES-
FROM OTHER COUNTRIES OF PLACES
WHERE. SOCIAL HOUSING IS HAS
WORKED I'M WITH US TODAY IS
THALIA. GONZALEZ CACHO WHO'S A
PROFESSOR AT ON MEXICO'S
MONTERREY INSTITUTE OF
TECHNOLOGY WE WILL THEN HEAR
FROM EDUARDO CABRERA ROMANS A
HOUSING POLICY CONSULTANT WITH
BARCELONA'S TO DEPARTMENT OF
HOUSING. AND DR WOLFGANG. AMMAN
A DIRECTOR OF THE INSTITUTE FOR
REAL ESTATE CONSTRUCTION
HOUSING IN VIENNA AUSTRIA- EACH
PRESENTER WILL HAVE ABOUT
TWELVE MINUTES AT 2% AND FIRST
WE WILL START WITH A PROFESSOR
CACHO. PROFESSOR CULTURE EITHER.
I'M PRESCOTT YOU ARE YOU ARE
YOU THERE. OKAY WE CAN WE CAN
MOVE ON TO THE SECOND PRESENTER
AND- HOPEFULLY PERCEPTIVENESS
OUR CULTURE WORLD WILL JOIN US-
SECOND- WE'LL HEAR FROM
EDUARDO- ROMANS ARE YOU
AVAILABLE EDUARDO. EDWARD ARE
YOU WITH US. OKAY WE'LL MOVE ON
TO HELP YOU ARE GREAT HI
EDUARDO THINK YOU'LL AND YOU'LL
HAVE ABOUT TWELVE MINUTES TO
PRESENT. GREAT I'M REALLY SORRY
THAT I. HE'S BUT WE AGREED
WITH- JOE WELL- WE'RE GONNA
HELP ME WITH THOSE THAT HE WILL
SHARE MY PRESENTATION WITH YOU
WHAT I'M GONNA BE USING MY
PHONE OUR MINDS ARE MANAGED.
RIGHT GREAT THANKS A LOT. ALL
RIGHT SO FIRST OF ALL THANK YOU
FOR HAVING ME HERE WITH YOU
TODAY- YOU ALREADY YOU CAN-
MAKE THE PRESENTATION IN FULL
SCREEN BECAUSE I DON'T I DON'T
THINK IT SHOWS. WELLNESS CENTER
WHICH- BUT ON THE YOU CAN JUST
THEM THAT WORKS OKAY SO- I USE
A LOT OF KOREA AM HOUSING. HIM
FOR- THE- BARCELONA HOUSING
APARTMENTS. I'M GONNA BE
TALKING TO YOU ABOUT OUR
POLITICS A SOCIAL AND
AFFORDABLE HOUSING PROGRAMS BUT
BEFORE I DO THAT- JORDAN SCROLL
DOWN. TO THE FOURTH FLIGHT
BECAUSE I DON'T HAVE MUCH TIME.
GOOD RIGHT HERE BUT I WAS. TOLD
THAT THE PREVIOUS ONE. SO
THAT'S ANOTHER HOUSING MODEL.
RIGHT THIS ONE GREAT. YES-
FIRST ALL AGES WANTED USUAL. ON
HOUSING IN SPAIN. SPAIN USED TO
BE ARM ANALYSIS- HOUSING.
ASSISTED IN BETWEEN- TENDENCIES
STARTING JAN- TENNIS OWNERS
RENTALS AND HOME OWNERSHIP IN
THE FIFTIES. BUT EVER SINCE-
THAT ARE GONNA STARTED
SUPPORTING HOMEOWNERSHIP.
SPECIALLY THROUGH- A-
AFFORDABLE HOMEOWNERSHIP
PROGRAM GOALS BEING THAT IF YOU
KNOW IF YOU HAVE. OF THE
COUNTRY'S SLOWLY MOVED INTO A
HOME OWNERSHIP- COUNTRY JUST
LIKE THE LAST ONE OF THE MOST
MARCH AND SO WHAT EMAIL THE
TOOL TOOL- THOUSANDS- WHAT WE
HAD IS A COUNTRY OFF 80% OF
MOURNERS TWENTY PERCENT.
RENTERS IT IS A LARGE IN A
LITTLE BIT DIFFERENT BECAUSE
WE'VE ALWAYS HAD TO BE- RANCHER
POPULATION. BUT STILL- THE
MAJORITY OF THE POPULATION
LIVES IN- IN- IN. A HARD EDGED
OR HOLD THEIR OWN. AND YOU LOOK
AT ONLY HAS THERE BECAUSE THE
COUNTRY ALSO SUPPORTED.
OWNERSHIP YOUR PORTAL HAS
SECTOR. THE RESULT IS THAT
TODAY'S SPACE IS ONE OF THE- WE
SHOULD BE AND WHAT OF YOUR
COUNTRY. WITH THE LEAST HOW.
AND WE HAVE LESS THAN TWO OR-
OR HOLIDAY STOCK BEING- SOCIAL
HORRIBLE- NOW. THANKS LIKE
PLEASE. WE CO CLOSE INSIDE-
WHAT WE WHAT WE SEE IS THAT IN
THE PAST TWO DECADES- DATING
CREASON HOUSING CRISIS WAS WAY
OFF- THE DECREASE IN IN
HOUSEHOLD INCOME THAT'S WHAT
THE GRAPH HERE SHOWS AROUND
THE- REPEATEDLY TO THE
FINANCIAL CRISIS. IT WAS A HUGE
INCREASE IN PRICES WENT DOWN
AGAIN BUT EVERYTHING'S- TWO
THOUSAND FIFTEEN PRICES ARE
GOING UP AGAIN WELL WHILE-
HUSTLING AND HASN'T HAS
INCREASED AS MUCH AS YOU CAN
SEE. THE FORECLOSURE CRISIS
THAT HAPPENED RIGHT AFTER THE
MIDDLE MANAGEMENT RICE'S HASN'T
REALLY BEEN SOLVED AS OF TODAY
WE STILL HAVE- ANY GORDON A
NUMBER OF FORECLOSURES
HAPPENING AS A RESULT OF-
MORTGAGE ON PAYMENTS AS WELL
AS- AS WELL AS RENTALS- THAT
ARE HOLDING FOR THE CLOTHES ON.
BUT HE DIDN'T WORK LOAN
OPPORTUNITY BECAUSE IF YOU SEEN
WE'VE SEEN A POLITICAL SHIFTS
MAINLY BECAUSE THE CURRENT
MAYOR- WE SEE ON THE SCREEN AND
WE USED TO BE- HOUSING ACTIVIST
WAS ELECTED IN TWO THOUSAND
EIGHTEEN I WILL BEGINNING THEM-
THE CITY HAS REALLY CHANGED IT
HOUSING POLICIES AND IS ONE OF
ME GOING TO BE TALKING TO YOU
ABOUT- TODAY. NASA SCIENCE. YOU
CAN JUST CALL THE FOLLOWING.
RIGHT SO THAT IS WANTED TO WHAT
THE ARTIST AS A FOR AND SOCIAL
HOUSING BECAUSE YOU RESULT WHAT
DO YOU THE SERVER YOU USE THE
UNITED STATES BUT IT MIGHT BE
EXACT THE SAME SO FERTILE
HOUSING IS IF I BUT ON. INCOME
BRACKETS. DIFFERENT TYPES OF-
WHO JUST YOU'RE IN A- ASSIST-
AND HE'S ON WE DEFINE- PRICES
SQUARE METER. THAT RESULTS IN A
RANGE OF AFFORDABLE GRANTS
THAT. ARE SLOWING WOULD RANGE
BETWEEN FIVE HUNDRED AND A
HUNDRED EUROS- THAT'S THE CASE
REGARDLESS OF THE- FINAL IN
CARMEL THAT IS THAT IS AT. YOU
DON'T FEED WITH ANY SINGLE
RACKETS BUT- BUT THE RANDY
STATES BASED ON- IT'S- YEAH
IT'S FIRST AND WOMEN RANGE. OF
HOUSING WE DEFINE THE RENTS
BASED ON THE INCOME OF THE
HOUSEHOLD. TO WHOM THE HEARING
HAS BEEN OUT OF THE- USE CASE
WE ARE LOOKING AT LOWER INCOME.
OF FAMILIES AND HOUSEHOLDS.
THAT ENDED UP BEING BETWEEN TWO
HUNDRED AND FOUR HUNDRED EUROS
YOU TO RENT SO THERE'S LESS.
BUT THE IMPORTANT PIECE HERE IS
THAT WE DON'T HAVE SEPARATE
UNITS FOR AFFORDABLE AND SOCIAL
WE'RE ONLY TALKING ABOUT THE
SAME UNITS. WHICH IS SURGERY
AFFORDABLE HOUSING UNITS AND
INDIVIDUAL SOCIAL HOUSING. WE
ARE TARGETING THE DIFFERENCE
BETWEEN THE SOCIAL RENT. FOR
THE- WITH THE GENERAL MANAGERS
PROVIDED YOU'RE ABOUT TO SEE
ORDER. WHICH IN OUR CASE. SORRY
YOUR CASE WILL BE THE STATE
GOVERNMENT. AT THE END OF THE
DAY OUT OF ALL THE HOUSING
COMPANIES GETTING THE SAME
AFFORDABLE HOUSING RENTS. WHICH
AS PROFESSOR. I SHOULD IS
REALLY KEEN TO ENSURE LAW TERM.
SUSTAINABILITY FOR ALL THE
HOUSING. THAT'S RIGHT. RIGHT
SEASON OF THE LITTLE FROM OF
THE HOUSING PROGRAM YOU JUST
OUR LONERS LITTLE CAN. WE
MAINLY TO MIDDLE INCOME HOW.
BUT ALSO IN SOME SB CD RUPES
JUST SUGGEST THE ELDERLY DO YOU
USE M. ALSO FORMAL HOMELESS AND
TO LONG. INCOME WOULD
INSTITUTIONAL PURPOSE. BUT IT
WILL NOT BE SURPRISED IF YOU
WILL WE HAVE A COMPANY OF ALL
GROUPS REDUCE. AS WELL AS A
SINGLE UNIT SO THE CITY HAS HAS.
YEAH PRIVATE- DONALD BUILDINGS
SO WE THIS IS THOSE TO SEE
ARAFAT- SOME- YOU ANY. OR OR-
WE HAVE A PART IN ONE OF THOSE
YOU AND IN THE MURDER ABOUT.
MINUTES LIGHT. SEVERAL HE TELL
US YOUR SOME PROGRAMS THE CITY
IS LAUNCHING BEGINNING BECAUSE
SIX. HERE YOU HAVE FROM AROUND
ISSUE OBVIOUS ARE JUST LOOKING
FOR THROUGH PROGRAMS THAT HE'S-
PROGRAMS- FINE. FINANCE DEVELOP
BY ISSUE IT IS. YOU READY OUT
OF SQUARE TO SEE PART WITH
NONPROFIT OR I WAS. WHO TO
REALLY MANAGED HOUSING AND
AGREE YOU'RE NOT RIVER SET OF
THE C. USERS ARE IN EXISTENCE
HOUSES. TO EITHER ACQUIRE.
ERDEM HOUSING OR TO MOVE IT
OVER BUT I DON'T WORKED HOUSING
THAT IS LIKE. IF YOU CAN ANSWER
TO- THE NEW ONE WITH FAST RIGHT
REALLY YEAH SO- IN TERMS OF ALL
HOUSING WHAT I WANT TO SHARE
YOUR USED R. THREE ONE THE C.
HAS. TO SOME THE LESS CREATED
THROUGH SOME MANY THAT ARE
DON'T UNIVERSITY THROUGH LAND
RESERVES ON ONE HAND REGIONALES.
TO RESERVE 4% OF ANY-
DEVELOPMENT HAVE IN GREEN BROWN
TO SEE FOR AFFORDABLE. AT SOME
FORTY PER GOES STRAIGHT IN THE
CITY SO CITY- IS HAS IT WILL A
CAN YOU TO DEVELOP HOUSING THE
CITY NOT THE 40% BASED ON IT IS
SET UP BY PRIVATE DEVELOPERS
WEARABLES REQUIRED TO. HAVE BUT
SOMEBODY TO GO TO THE C.
ENTITIES UNABLE LIST SEE GET A
SLANTED ALEX ALREADY HAS IS
WHAT SHOULD WE USE SCIENCE WE
DON'T OF PRODUCTS THROUGH- GOT
THE BEST MAN BUT WILL GET A-
FROM THE THIS HOUSING PLAN. IT
WE ALSO FINANCE- PROJECTS WITH
A LOANS BY THE REGIONAL PUBLIC-
BANK YES YES I ALSO TO EUROPEAN
ALL THE BANKS THAT LENT MONEY
TO- TO- STARTING A STRETCH AT A
NONPROFIT IS BUILDING PUBLIC
HOUSING OR OR SOCIAL HOUSING
AND OTHER EARLY I JUST ALWAYS
MEASURE THAT OUR PUBLIC HOUSING
BUILDINGS IN THE CITY ARE SOME
OF THE MOST YOU KNOW NOBODY'S
SINGLE STARSHIPS- AND SO WE
WE'VE BEEN OP RELEASED FOR
BEING VERY NOBODY. ENJOYS OF
CONSTRUCTION BEGINS AS WELL.
THAT IS LIKELY EARNS. SO WHAT
IS THE BEST YEAR HE'S USED
SEVERAL INSTRUMENTS TO ROLL I
REQUIRED THOSE UNITS HAD
PRIVATE. RIGHT ABOUT YOU UP TO
THAT TO THAT EVEN THE BRIGHTEST-
RIGHT AT- HOLDERS DON'T WANT TO
SET IT TO US SO WE HAVE SEVERAL
EMPTION RIGHTS AND RICE.
REFUSAL CERTAIN CIRCUMSTANCES
ARMENIANS OF THE L. BUT I HAVE
CUSTOMER WAYS WHICH WE BY
WHENEVER YOU A PRIVATE. IN OUR
WHERE INTEREST IN ACQUIRING IT
THE PRIVATE MARKET RATES BUT
WILSON AND GETTING DEALS WHEN
IT IS- THE DIVERSITY ONLY. OR
AT LEAST. WE TRIED TO PREVENT
FROM HAVE- BY ACCORDING UNITS
IF YEAH LOOK OF WHERE. IN
BUYING OR PRICE YOU ATTRACTIVE
AT LEAST HOUSE FEW YEARS. OF
THE NUMBER UNITS THE CITY A
CORE AND THE PRICING- AND OUR
LITTLE TWENTY TWENTY ONE
ACQUIRED MORE THAN SHE HUNDRED
UNITS THE NEW PROGRAM. THAT'S
RIGHT. THE THIRD. MINUTES LEFT.
YES THANK YOU THE THIRTY THREE
WITH THE CITY IS TRYING
INCREASE ITS POLITICS ARE JUST
TALK. AND STARTED TO MOBILIZE
AND HER MORE RELAXED RIGHT SO
WE HAVE TO BROWN OR TO THAT THE
FIRST ONE A RENTAL POOL IN
WHICH THE CITY. BETWEEN TENNIS
AND A LOT MORE AND IMPROVISED
EXECUTIVE OR TO RENT THOSE ARE
THE LOWER PRICE YOU HAVE A LIST
TO BE SET IS GOING A HOME-
RUSSELL INTO THE DETAILS NOW
WHAT WE RELEASED ALMOST THIRD
YOUR I MEAN TO JUST BROKE AS OF
TODAY MINUTES LINE. SO IT IS
REALLY A SESSION HAPPENING HERE
BETWEEN A LANDLORD AND
EVOLUTION OF THE FOUNDATION OF
A SPORTING OR RENTING THE UNITS
TO THE DEFENSE- ANSWERED SAID
AS LIGHT. PLEASE THE THIRD
PROGRAM. THAT HAS TO DO WITH
MOBILIZING CREDIT HOUSING IS OF
A VERY REASONABLE AROUND. TOO
MORE LINES- OF RELEASING ORDERS
THAT HAVE NOT BEING USED DURING
THAT. I NAME. PROVIDES A
SUBSIDY. TO BRIDGE THAT BETWEEN
WHAT THE SENATE CAN BE FOR THE-
YOUR AS FAR HOUSING. AND
WATCHED THE PROPERTY ALL- ARE
WILLING TO ACCEPT. NEXT SLIDE
I'M GONNA JUST STROLL TO THE
END OF MY PRESENTATION I WANT
TO SHARE WITH YOU. SOME. ALL OF
THE- PARTITION INSTEAD WE'RE-
THE REST OF DOWN. TO THE NEXT
SLIDE. ONE WILL WOULDN'T YOU
SAID I'M SORRY WITH SO MANY PRO.
WHICH WAS A SOME OF THE THAT
YOU'RE YOUR- SO I'M GONNA GET
IT DONE. ONE THE SECOND ONE IS
LARGELY HOW. THE CITY TO
PROVIDE QUALITY HOUSING TO
WATER USE THAT ADEQUATE HOUSING
DOT. THE DIFFERENT PROGRAMS AND
THINGS. YOU CAN CHECK. ON IT IS
LIKELY YOUR ON. AND I'M JUST
GONNA THROW THEM THE CHAU IS
LIKE AT THE VERY HANDS. SO OVER
GOING SURE THAT HE'S VERY TO
HAVE YOU- FUNDING FINANCE STORY
OUT DO YOU. WE ARE VERY MUCH
ABOUT ON. CAPITAL BY SEE A IS
AN IMPROVED BE THERE. ALSO READ-YOU. REPUBLICAN HOUSE SOURCE
HOUSING. I WILL A- OF ALL OF
ALL THE WILL BE A TO. RIGHT OF
THE ON THE WRONG. THANK. ALSO
THAT ZONING LIVE A MINUTE
OPPORTUNITY AS OFF YOUR OF
WHERE YOU CAN BILL ALSO. YOUR
LIKE COULD YOU TO FIND ALL THE
WAYS TO PROVIDE FULL. FOR THE
FIRST. AN HONORS. ALL READ THE
JOURNAL WORLD THE SOCIAL PORTAL
SHE'S VERY LITTLE SO YOU HAVE
TO BE A- THAT MOVE FORWARD YOU
NEED TO KEEP ANDREAS.
AFFORDABLE HOUSING BECAUSE YOU
WON'T SEE MUCH OR- OVER JUST
UNIT. AT A LOSS NIGHT WE- DO SO
THE LESSONS WE LEARN. CERVANTES
RELATED DISABILITY RIGHTS TO
THE DANCE AND THE COMMUNITY AT
LARGE- ALSO THAT YOU YOU YOU
SHOULD HELD ON ON VOTING RIGHT-
AND ABILITY TO COMMUNITY
COLLABORATIONS. TO PROVIDE- OF
SOME OF THE THAT HAS BEEN ONE
OF THE LEADING WRONG. IT ALSO
THE MANAGER. BECAUSE I THINK
IT'S VERY REMINISCENT OF THEM
ENGAGED ON THE DAILY MANAGEMENT
AND ALL OF THE UNITS. I AM VERY
SORRY TO HAVE I JUST YOU WOULD
THE INFORMATION THAT ALSO WITH
THE. EXACTLY HAVING BUT I HOPE
THAT- THE MAIN POINTS. BEING-
RIGHT. YOU VERY MUCH THAT WAS A
VERY INFORMATIVE WE PRE AND
WILL COME BACK TO DURING Q. AND
A PORTION- ONCE WE HEAR FROM
THE REST OF OUR SPEAK- WE'RE
GONNA CHECK AND SEE IF CACHO IS
ON. AND ON MUTED PROFESSOR ARE
YOU THERE. PROFESSOR CACHO ARE
YOU THERE AND ARE YOU AND YOU
DIDN'T. OKAY HOPEFULLY WE CAN
GET HER- WE CAN MOVE ON TO DR
WOLFGANG. AMMAN DR WITH A MINOR
YOU ARE YOU ON AND AVAILABLE.
SWINDLING. PLEASE SHARE MY
SCREEN. LET ME YEP AND WE CAN
HEAR YOU AND YOU'LL HAVE ABOUT
TWELVE MINUTES. TALKING ABOUT
THE YELLOW HOUSING. ASSEMBLY
MAMMALS AND ON EACH YEAR WEEKS.
SO ARE YOU PLANNING SALUTE
SOLUTIONS- WE CONCEDED
APPROACHES ALL OVER THE WORLD
WE HAVE THE ONE MODEL FOR THE
LAND. WHICH IS WHAT ESTABLISHED
USER SELLING IN THE U. S. A.
MONTREAL FRANCE WE HAVE SOME OF
THE ONE OF THE FOLLOWING OF
THAT LEGISLATION ALSO SHARES IN
FRENCH IT IT HAD A PIECE.
VETERANS WE HAVE RENTAL HOUSING
FOR EXAMPLE THIS WEEK'S STREET
SIGNATURE MUNICIPAL HOUSE
COMPANY AND COURSE KNOW USE IT.
WE HAVE FIVE PEOPLE OF THE
PRIVACY WILL BE IS WHAT. THE
NEW HOUSING TAX CREDITS USE AND
WHAT IS A LITTLE SHE HASN'T.
USE TO IN MY- AND WE HAVE I
DIDN'T KNOW OF ONE LITTLE OLDER.
RIGHT HOUSING- MOVE SIGNIFICANT
THE CITY WILL PROBABLY CALL
WE'LL SEE PROGRAM WHICH ONLY
SAKE EIGHT PEOPLE OF. WERE AND
IN FINLAND YOU HAVE. THIS
LIMITED PRODUCTS HOUSING
ASSOCIATIONS AND ENGAGE EIGHT.
WHICH IS QUITE SIMILAR TO THE
NAME STAPLETON FRONTS AND
WINNABLE CORPORATE SEAT IN THE
LAND OF METAL METAL AND CYSTINE
IN THE- IN THE- THE PHARMACIST
OF HIS LUNAR THAT SO. BILLS-
KIND PLEASE. THE NETHERLANDS
AND ALL YEAH I'M- DELUDE J.
HOUSING VOTE. SO ARE I'M THE
GLAD. OF RELATED ARTICLES IN-
SEE HIS WE ARE. AT IN STRONG
EASY TO USE WITH US BUSINESS
CASE ORIENTED TO GROW FOR
AFFORDABLE. HOUSING MINISTER
HOUSING AB THE APPLICATION AND
NOTHING ELSE. WE SAW THE NEED A
FRAMEWORK AND AUDITING. AND
FROM THIS USE AS WELL EVEN
SMALL I WAS. TO PERFORM WELL.
SEEM TO REPORT STEP DAD IS A SO
THAT IS A DECISION ARE NOT TO
WHAT THEY WANT SOME YEAH A
CRISIS. STEALING BEST YOUR
OPPONENTS GOES ON A PROVISION
THAT. YOU TOO SETTLEMENT. UNITY
THOUSAND SCHEMES AND YOUTUBE
POLITICS ALL THE SCHEMES.
FINALLY IT IS EASY TO SAID
WHICH IS MAY TO LAST IT'S
ALREADY ABOUT ONE YEARS. AND IT
HAS TO DATE OF ANY WORLD
POLITICAL BACK. US WHAT DO NOT
OWN FROM THE DEMOCRATIC PARTY
AND THE CONSUMER PARTY ALSO
FROM THE NEIGHBORS FROM THE
GREEN PARTY AND EVEN FROM THE
RIGHT WING. FREEDOM. I MEAN IF
YOU SINCE TWO WHO FOR. EIGHT
ABA CERTIFICATIONS THIS-
EARNING FROM UNIVERSITIES. ARE.
AND SON HE'S- NOTES NOT SOME-
NICE TO GO THE- GENERAL. CITY
IS BECAUSE OF A GOOD OPINION.
WHILE SOME OF THE PROBLEMS HE
FIRST HOW WANT TO KEEP ALSO HAS
SOME FORM MILLION HOUSING UNITS
AND ONE MEETING IN OF THOSE
HOUSING UNITS BEEN. BY HOUSING.
HERE INSTRUCTIONAL PROCESS
PROCESSING EIGHTY THOUSAND
UNITS WHICH EQUALS ROUGHLY
THIRTY TO FIFTY THOUSAND- FIFTY
THIRTY FIFTY PERCENT. YOU THE
SERGEANTS. OUR I THINK IT IS
YEAH- HOUSING ESTATE THE IN
EAST LOOKING. OUR THE SEATTLE
HAS IT S. COST FORMS VISUAL ON
THE MARKET. IT HAS ALSO THE-
YOU ALL MARKET SIX. YOU TOO-
RAFI TO YOUR ASSEMBLY PERFORM
ON THE SHOW INTO IT IF I. THE
SECOND IS BONTA SO AND IT
ARTICLE STATED. WE GOT FINE
MANUAL HOUSING IS ASIANS HAVE A
VERY HIGH. MYRTLE CUTE FIND
HOUSE. BECAUSE OF MEDICAL
REASONS AN ACCIDENT CREDITEASE.
I'LL CITIES IN NEW CONSTRUCTION
ACCOUNT FOR APPROXIMATELY 20%
OF CONSTRUCTION COSTS IN CASH
VALUE WHICH IS ROUGHLY THE SAME
S. A. B. A. T. V. EIGHT WHICH
IS CREATED THROUGH NEW
CONSTRUCTION SO THE SUBSIDY IS
BASICALLY THAT WAS THE STATE
EARNS FROM YOUR PERCEPTION OF.
SOCIAL OPTIONS. IT IS SERVICE
INVOLVED A STATE EXPENDITURES
ON HOUSING. WE DIDN'T TOTAL
ROUGHLY- ZERO POINT 5% OF GDP
IF YOU COMPARE WITH OTHER
EUROPEAN COUNTRIES WE ARE THE
LOWEST. OF ALL EUROPEAN
COUNTRIES. INDIANA THERE'S
ARTICLE AND IT IS- DISCOUNTED
MANKO. YOU YOU WERE GOING TO
SIT OUR FUNDS BOND WHICH IS AN
EASY WE IS TO OF THE HIGHER OF
LAND BANKING CANNELLA. HIS LAN
AND YOU FOR SUBSIDIZED HOUSING
IT IS CURRENTLY ONE OF RAFI
MILLION SCANDAL. REGARDING
RECENT MEDIA- ARE THE DECISIONS
NO REAL IT WAS TO BELOW MARKET
UTILIZED SO RATES. YEAH NO MAN
LISTS USING ALL THE INCLUDES.
YEAH NO FINANCING. YOU TOO
CITIES AND SO EVERY REYES. WE
GOT COMMITTEE. IN SOME PROBLEMS
REGARDING ESTADIO COMPETITION
BETWEEN HOUSING ASSOCIATIONS
AND COMMERCIAL HOUSING
DEVELOPERS SO MANY DEANNA
COMMERCIAL HOUSING DEVELOPERS
ARE HOST TO DEBATE IN
COMPETITIONS FOR SUBSIDIES AND
FOR DISCOUNT ITS BILLING THEN.
FOR AFFORDABLE- SUBSIDIZE
HOUSING. IN MOST OF THE PROMISE
IS HE HAD A COMPETITIVE AWARDS
ALSO CITIES AND IT IS A STATE
AT SOME DIFFERENT HOUSING
ASSOCIATIONS OFFER PROJECTS AND
WOUNDED THOSE WITH THE BEST
QUALITY WE'LL GET THE SUBSIDY.
REGARDING VALIDITY. RENTS ARE
IN THE- HOUSING- IN THAT MAYBE
THE PROBLEM CAUSING SIGNALS TO
THE OP ED ABOUT THE STATEMENT
WAS FIVE UTICA SQUARE METER
EIGHT DOLLARS GALA PER MONTH
INCLUDING MAINTENANCE COSTS IN
THE EIGHTY WHICH IS
APPROXIMATELY. 25% BELOW. HENCE
ALSO ALL THE STATE HOUSE COSTS
OF SURE FAMILY LOW THAT YOU
EVER TEACHER SEE WITH LIMITED
ROUGH ARE BELOW SO IN P. L. A.
SUNG. ROUGHLY 22% OF THE IRAQI
THANK YOU TO SEND OFF- OF THE
DISPOSAL HOUSEHOLD INCOME TO BE
SPENT FOR. LAWS IT IS ON BEST.
OF A PERCENT. STATIONS ARE KEY
AND SO E PUTS THE BECAUSE OF
NATION YEAH FROM PRADA AND
EFFICIENCY AND ECONOMIC
PERFORMANCE. OKAY YOU CAN SEE
HERE IS ONE OF THE- AS YOU.
STATE MEANWHILE SOME TWENTY OR
30% OFF FOLLOWING THE STATE'S
REALIZED BY ORGANIZATIONS-
WITHOUT SOME EXTERNAL ENERGY
FOR. AND WHO WE- THERE IS
ALMOST SUCCESS INNOVATION ON.
THOSE PROGRAMS MS OF WHAT CAN
IN THIS WORLD YOU ALSO I OF
ARCHITECTURE. IN MANY CASES ARE-
I ACTUAL COMMUNITIES OUR. I THE
SECOND IN A SO WE HAVE FROM AS
LAW WE GOT OF REGULATING SECTOR
ABUSE IS ON THE PROBLEM HOUSING.
OWNERS OF THESE HOUSING THE
CITY ARE- PARTLY. I BELIEVE IT
IS FAMILIES FINANCING THREE
GENTLENESS AND TOURS. ROBIN W.
MASON SAID SADDAM 44% OF OPEN
HOUSE STOCK AND IF YOU REALLY
BY IDOLS HOUSING ASSOCIATIONS
AND OF THIRD TO THE PERCENT. OF
THE YOU WILL GET A LOT OF
CONSTRUCTION IS ADVISE. A VERY
IMPORTANT I USED TO EASE. THAT
HOUSE. ALL MADE PROFITS. BUT
WOULD HAVE TO BE THIS IN ORDER
HOW. UNIVERSITIES ALL FIVE
HUMANS THEN AND BECAUSE BY. YES
HELLO- AVAILABLE ONE. ARAFAT
THE DAILY STANCIL I'M SKILLS WE
SERVE WE ALSO THE. THEY
FOLLOWED ACOSTA REMAINS. LINK
WITH YOU COMPONENTS OPERATING
SO DATE TO OF THEM IS THE MAKE
PROFITS AND MANY OF. DECISIONS
AS QUITE SOME SUBSTANTIAL. AND
IN EASILY OF COURSE TIE UP
OFFICE. SO I WAS THE STORES
CARE BE CASH OUT. I TOLD ANI
FOR EXAMPLE THE FINDINGS
LOOKING INTO APPROACH. I LUZON
CAN WHO FALLS. AND SO. ST ALL
CONTROL MINUTE PLEASE. THREE
CONTROL. THE NEXT MINUTE YES
NOT A PRESENTATION AND FINAL
FLIGHT- WITH THIS- OKAY I HAVE
A LITTLE ONE EIGHT I'LL BE ONE
ENTITY HELLO STILL MAYBE HE WAS.
HIS IN OUR SELF YEAH AND ONE OF
THE TOOL DAISY- DOES SOME
SETTLEMENTS- WE HAD USUALLY-
SEE FAMILY HOMES- ARE PLACED
THANK GOODNESS AND. YOU HEAR
ME. HELLO WE CAN HEAR YOU AND
YOU'LL HAVE ABOUT TWELVE
MINUTES.
ZERO AND AGREED A.
HELLO MY NAME IS THE NAME SIZE
NINETEEN MAKE THINK ON OUR
VISIT AT A MINIMUM DAY. GOT
MONTEREY. I GONNA AT SOLUTION
HOUSING AND MAKING. YOU KNOW HE
MANAGES HE SAID THEY- HAVE
EVERY CD WE ALSO SHOULD HOUSING
SCAN OF THE- THING HI ALL I
KNOW IT IS THREE IN THE AND IN
A WAY THAT HE ACTS DOES SEAT.
SUIT YOU KNOW SEE THAT A V.
THEY ARE ANY LESS LONGER GAMING
AND. HELLO BOTHER BECAUSE
THREE. I MOVIE POLICIES HAVE
BEEN WHEN WE STARTED
UNDERSTANDING THE MAKING
CONSTITUTION EAT ACT THEY WERE
VERY. THE OTHER SOLVE HOUSING
CALL M. SAID DON'T ASIAN ON THE
YEARS OF CALL EITHER AT HOME OR
THAN ONE WORD. THE BRIDE THEM
AND HAND BLESSINGS THE. I MEAN
I HAVE A PEOPLE WAS WORKING
ITSELF RATION AND MAINLY MOST
OF THE HOUSES WERE THE. MEXICO
TO SEE SOMEBODY'S JOB. LEADING
REYES OF THE BEACH THAT GREAT A
VERY BROAD IS FROM THE FIFTIES
TO SEVENTY FIVE AS WELL AS EASY
SHOWS THAT HERE YOU ARE THERE
TO THE FROM THE FROM THEM. AND.
ONE OF THEM. I FOR AND THAT'S
PART OF THE WELL YOU GOT
ANYTHING HOUSING BACK FINANCING.
THEY HAVE FINE YEAH WELL WE GOT
RID HE'S TIME ALSO SHOULD HAVE
WERE YOU YOU MAY HE GOES SEATED
WHILE THE MOM WELL NOW HE SAID.
YOU HAD IN MIND FROM. NINETEEN
FIFTY. THESE PROBLEMS ABOUT
MORE FOR I'LL AID TEAM FOR IN
ORDER TO SOLVE. WE FAST AND
HEALTH PROBLEMS HER FACE THAT
THE FALLING. LEHRER IN THE HE
SAID WE GET INSIDE YOU KNOW
HE'S NOT MAKE THE CITY. AS
LEAST YOU BE ONE OF THE MOST
CROWDED AIMS HOUSING YOU NEED
TO HAVE BUT YEAR WE HAVE A THEY
AREN'T WE MAKE NINE MAJOR. NOT
THESE POINTS WE GO THEN HAVING
TO BE THAT WE LAST HOUSING WAS
EIGHTEEN DAYS YOU GO. THIRTY
AREN'T GOING ANY KIND OF FOR
AND BE THEM THAT'S WHY THEY
HAVE THE FREE STEAM
DISTILLATION WE'RE WE'RE
WORKING MORE ON THE- MORRISON
WE AND HE SEES MAY IT HUGE
RIGHT CREATING MANY GO BECAUSE
OUR SEATS. ARE A STRONG THE AND
YOU STILL NEED TO THE FIVE THAT
THEY BY NAME. AND EXTERNALLY
RESUME HE GO HE'S CHEAPER THAT
ON THEIR OWN I PROCESSES- NOW
AND HE'S PAGO HIDING FROM FIVE
DAYS. IN WE ARE MAKING- THESE
HOUSES AVAILABLE FOR EVERY
MONTH THEY WANT TO GET A SUMMER
FETE BURBANK AND LOVE THAT ARE
CHEAPER AND CHEAPER EVERY TIME.
WHAT HAVING ON THE SERVER YEAH-
RECEIPT. SO AT. THE LEAST FROM
NOW IT WILL DIDN'T. AS EVEN
EASY MEDICAL MARIJUANA MEET HER
**** SAYS- HEATING CREATE YOU.
THEY THE WORD IS THE FIRST I'VE
BETTER IN PROBABLY. HE SAID.
AND ASKED BY SCHOOL THE
GOVERNMENT WAS AND- MAYES. AND
HEALTH READ ONE ON RIGHT SO
THEY SURE NEEDS BY THEY. I ON
TRAGEDY MAKING BE ON THE RIGHT
HI FOR EVERY IF YOU HAVE A
AGAIN HOW. BUT IF YOU THAT WE
HAVE FOR ALL JOBS IF YOU WERE
TO SEND OVER YOUR MAKE YOU GO
HARM FOR. SO WHENEVER YOU TRY
LEAGUE THE NEW YORK. BLACK. I
DON'T THAT HE NEED OR YOU WANT
BE THE YEAH. I BUSY GONNA
PRISON THAT OF YOUR EVERY
THROUGH THE WORK EASIER TO GET
A HOUSE THE COVER THAT SEEKS
PRESERVE OUR OF THE NATION HE'S
NOT HI VIS PROD BECAUSE THEY
ARE NOT BEING NICE. SO AS BEST
LINE. NOW FOR THE LAST FEW ONLY
OTHER SIDE IN IT YOUR SEE THE.
ASIAN CAN ACTUALLY A AND
RECEIPT YEAH. WELL YOU'RE NOT
L. EITHER ISSUE OUT OF SEE THEM
THAT ARE ACTUALLY TAKING ABOUT
THIS OF THE M. FIVE. BE MASKED
MAN THE YOU NEED FOR US THEN
AND SEE GOING HE JUST ABOUT ON
A RANGE. ANY GROWS OF EITHER
FOR THE STATE OF THE MIGHT. ALL
RIGHT NINE. YOU POINT EIGHT HE
SET AS IN SOME OTHER AS EASY
AND PRETTY POINT FIVE SAN A
DECLINE ON BERMAN AFTER A. BUT
REALLY I PROBABLY NEED THE NOT
THERE HEY. THAT SHE THE
SIZEABLE THE PHONE SHE YOU MAY
BE GOING TO GET MORE FIVE
MEANING THAT ARE. THERE IS I
MEAN I NOW. AND LONG LONG DAY
FOR NINE PESOS. SO IT MEANS
REALLY MEANS THAT YOU LEARN TO
BE A NAY YEAH USE. HAVE ONE OF
YOU NEED DVR ND THE HOUSE
BECAUSE OF CRIMINAL. WE GOT THE
GLOVER THAT SAID THREE POINT
SEEKS ME. MAKES ARE ACTUALLY
EXCUSE FROM FROM HOUSING RIGHT.
WE ARE I- FROM HAVE. MAY READ
WE HAVE A- YOUR THE LAST ONE I
NEED- GOES FOR THAN EIGHT PER
OF THE PERCENT WE HE ASKED EVEN
HI THAN SOME REGULAR BANK. ROLE.
WHAT PEOPLE GONNA GO OVER THE
PHONE WELL BECAUSE AT IS. A
HUGE WERE AT. YOUR AND EARLY UP
HOT YOUR SITE. AND TO ME HOW
THEN HE HE THEY ARE HANDS THAT
YOU CAN- EIGHT WAY WHEN I
REALLY. IN ON ACCOUNT WHEN I
MEET UP MEANS THE THAT STATE
RIGHT OR IF YOU NEED AND. WHERE
ARE WE YOUR AGE MUST BE TO
CREATE TRASHY GAZE FIVE EIGHT
SO YOU. READY ON THE FIRST PAGE
OF THE LAST TWO YEARS MAYBE FOR
YOU THEN YOU GOT IN EARLY
TWENTY FIVE YEARS UNITED
COMMUNITY THINKING ABOUT YOU
EARLY VERY EMAIL AND- FARTHER
YEAH WELL HOW YOU. LEADING
ROUTE THAT. THEN HE THOUGHT
ABOUT OVER THOSE THAT ACT
BECAUSE IF I YOU FOR A- IN THE
SUIT. WHAT VERY. B. B. THAT
MAKES YOU GO SEE THE GAME OFF
OR CELEBRATED NOT THEY ARE NOT
HAS CHOSEN NOT THE EVENING.
HAVE HER YOU KNOW THERE IS HE
L. SO RATHER GO THERE ARE MANY
A MASS NON IS A. HAVING SAID.
COMMISION YOU MODEL WHERE THERE
EATING SOMETHING CORRECT ME
THINKING NONTRADITIONAL PEOPLE
UNDERSTAND HOW TO MAKE THESE A
ALREADY HOW IN A MANNER WE'RE
AND THINGS LIKE EXAMPLE THE.
THREE EIGHT THREE. EIGHT
COMPARISONS THE CREDIT
REGAINING SAYS THESE REALLY YES
YOU SHOULD BE FRIENDS THANK THE
SCENE POMPON WRISTBAND- ALSO
TRANSACTION. THEN ABOUT MINUTES
LEFT. IT DOESN'T REALLY.
ASSEMBLY MEMBER EVEN. EATING-
THAT REPLACE I THINK PROBLEM.
THAT MAY SHE LED HE'S WORKING
ON ALICE SO THAT CD FOR THE AND
ON THE TWO THOUSAND SIX. VERY
THE GONNA I'M GONNA KEEP IT
DOESN'T SHOW ON THE MONITOR
FIVE YOU HAVE YOUR TAKE YOUR A
NEW PLAN FOR MANAGING WE HAVE A
WHOLE. LONG AND ONLY YOU'RE
GONNA SEE THESE PROCESS RED.
I'M GONNA SEE MORE AND THE-
MORE IN FROM GOVERNOR IN THE
MORNING AND I'M GOING FOR THE
PEOPLE ARE TO BUY YEAH. THE
EARTH NO ONE OF MY- OUTS OF THE
FUNDING A GREEN. I KNOW ONLY
RIGHT IN THE EVEN IF THE-
GUINEAS OTHER RATE BY NOW I. OF
THEM THERE HAVE ARE. SAID
CREATED RIGHT NOW. THESE WAY
THAT HAVE. NOT TO THE CORONER
THAT HOUSING ACTUALLY GETTING
EMAILS. NAME I PLACES A OFFICE
HE- DOES BE FAST OKAY WELL
ABOUT EIGHTY SEE THAT. WE BUT
SOCIAL. HOUSING A HAS ACTUALLY.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR THAT
INFORMATIVE PRESENTATION- AND-
I DON'T KNOW IF FOLKS MOST
APPARENTLY THE POWERS OUT IN
OAKLAND FOR ABOUT FOURTEEN
THOUSAND SO I THINK ROADS AND
CONNECTIVITY ISSUES AND
CHALLENGES TODAY- BUT WHEN I
THINK THE PANELISTS- FOR THE
REMARKS AND ALSO JUST REMIND
FOLKS THAT ARE IN THE ROOM
TODAY. IT'S BEEN A LITTLE HARD
TO SEE THE PRESENTATIONS AND
THE AUDIENCE BEEN CHALLENGING
BUT- THIS IS ALL BEING STREAMED
AND THE PRESENTATIONS ARE ARE
ON THE STREAMING IF YOU WANT TO
GO BACK AND REVIEW SOME OF
THOSE- SEPARATELY AND I DON'T
THINK THERE ARE ANY
CONNECTIVITY ISSUES FOR THE
SPRING PORTION OF THIS- O
THAT- WILL. IT BE EASY FOR YOUR
REFERENCE IF YOU WANT TO
REFLECT ON THAT AND WE WILL
HAVE TIME NOW FOR Q. NA- FOR
MYSELF AND MY COLLEAGUES FOR
THE PANELISTS- WOULD LOVE TO
KICK OFF THE FIRST QUESTION-
FOR DOCTOR. AMMAN FROM VIENNA I
IF I READ THIS CORRECTLY ABOUT
A QUARTER OF THE HOUSING IS
RESERVED FOR SOCIAL HOUSING
EFFECTIVELY- CORRECT ME IF I'M
WRONG ON THAT ASSESSMENT AND
THEN. THE QUESTION I HAVE FOR
YOU IS WHAT IS THE HOMELESSNESS
RATE- IN YOUR COUNTRY GIVEN
THAT YOU HAVE SO MUCH SOCIAL
HOUSING AND IS. ALMOST AS AN
ISSUE THAT YOU ALL CONFRONT.
VISUALLY ON THE STREETS AND YOU
SEE FOLKS ERRORS OR- TO
SOCIALIZING REALLY ACCOMMODATE-
THAT ISSUE. YEAH ARE
HOMELESSNESS IS NOT THAT EASY
TO EVALUATE BECAUSE IT TOOK
PLACE ON MARCH. MOST RECENT
NAMA HE SETS THERE ARE SOME
TWENTY THOUSAND PERSONS. IN A
YEARLY AVERAGE. EATING WITHOUT-
ALL OF THEM I DON'T. WANT YEAR
A- AS HAVE FAR ALMOST AS MANY
CASES. FOR OUR OLDEST SO
ACTUALLY ON THE RULES YOU CAN
SEE PEOPLE UNLESS THOSE ARE-
HAD A BLUE LED SET SAID IN IN
AUSTRIA. PHOTOS SO SOMETIMES
YOU CAN SEE SOME OF AND UP
SLOTS IN THE CITY'S NOT INDIANA
AND. FLOODING ROOMS ASUS. IS IT
YOUR THAT BECAUSE YOU HAVE SUCH
ROBUST WERE BOTH ROBOTS SOCIAL
HOUSING- THAT THIS IS PART OF
THE REASON WHY YOU'RE SUCH A
LOW. HOMELESS RATE. EVIDENTLY
NOT THE MODEL MELISSA HOW'S THE
SAKE OF YOU HAVE. HE SYSTEM.
AND I'M AND- OF SUBSIDIES
PEOPLE WHO HAVE TO GO OUT.
THANK YOU. AND WITH THAT ONE
OPEN UP Q. AND A TO MY
COLLEAGUES EITHER OF YOU HAVE
QUESTIONS ASSEMBLY MEMBER LEE
YES I DO HAVE A QUESTION TO DR
WOLFGANG AMMAN AS WELL- WHEN
YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT THE
LIMITED PROFIT HOUSING
ASSOCIATIONS L. P. H. A. I KNOW
THE DEFINITION CLUE THAT'S
PRIVATE OWNERS AND IN THAT IS
THAT IS SAYING A PRIVATE
INDIVIDUAL HOMEOWNERS OR SAY
PRIVATE LANDOWNERS AND
DEVELOPERS. IN THAT ALLIANCE.
ON MAY. BE INFORMED- OF THE
CASE- FOR EXAMPLE IN ONE WHICH
IS THE BIGGEST TEST TO DATE-
MORE THAN FIFTY THOUSAND
HOUSING UNITS. WAS CREATED IN
THE NINETEEN FIFTIES BY.
EDUCATING AT EIGHT CAPITAL A
WITH A AMOUNT OF MONEY AMOUNT
OF- INVESTMENT AND BILL UP ALL
THESE COMPANIES HUGE. OF
COMPLETED IT'S NOT SETTLED
ALBANY'S WITH THE HELP OF FARM
SUBSIDIES BUT ALSO THE SYSTEM
WHERE THE PAYMENT WAS PAID- THE
MORTGAGES AND SOME REDEFINES.
DURING SUMMERTIME OVERTIME
MEANWHILE OF MAIL STILL SAYS.
ANALYZE AND STUDY CREATE
ADDITIONAL ACTIVITY- TO THE
COMPANY WHICH- MUST BE DIPLOMA.
BECAUSE OF THE LIMITATIONS
REINVESTMENTS IN AFFORDABLE
HOUSING AND THE ACQUISITION OF
LEADING MAN SO YES THERE ARE
STILL IN THE WORKS WHICH ARE.
ALMOST IN SOME CASES- ARKANSAS
INTO- THAT'S UP. THIS IS THE
CASE ONE OF ONE ISSUE ALL. THE
FINANCING PARTISAN TO BE A AN
IMPORTANT CITY ALSO HOUSING-
ENABLES YEAH WE HAVE FOUR
EXAMPLE- YEAH JUNE SCHOOL AND
SO RIGHT MASON WHICH WHOSE A
VERY SAN SAY IN SEVERAL LIMITED
PRODUCT ASSOCIATION. ARE OUT TO
HAVE A PROGRAM THAT'S- YOU CAN
GENERATE ONLY EIGHTEEN A PHONE
CALL FROM AN ESSENTIAL THREE
POINT 5% A YEAR WHICH IS NOT TO
BE SUFFICIENT FOR THEM I DO NOT
ALLOW US TO INCREASE- THE BOOK
VALUE OFF THEIR STAKES IN THOSE
COMPANIES AND THEY DO MAKE SOME
FRAZIER- THROUGH- THERE-
PROBABILITY. REALLY TODAY AND
THEN ANSWER MEAN DEATH WITH.
DEFINITELY WITH SOCIAL HOUSING
CIRCLE VIENNA SEEN AS ONE OF
THE PRIMING YOU LOOKED WEAR OFF
AND I JUST HAD A FALL UP
QUESTION WITH THEM THAT TO IS-
SO OBVIOUSLY YES YOU DID READ
L. P. H. AS HAVE ABOUT A
QUARTER SHARE OF THE HOUSING
STOCK IN VIENNA IS L. PH H. IS
THAT SHARE DISTINCT FROM
STRICTLY MANSA BALL. THE CITY
DONE PUBLIC HOUSING. NO YEAH.
RELATIONAL FALL ALMOST TWO
MILLION INHERITANCE- THERE ARE
ROUGHLY ONE MILLION HOUSING
UNITS. ARE AROUND TWO HUNDRED
TEN THOUSAND HOUSING UNITS ARE
OLD IDEAS L. EAT WHICH IS
MUNICIPAL HOUSING AND IN
ADDITION SOME ONE HUNDRED
EIGHTY THOUSAND HOUSING UNITS
YOU SOLD BLIGHTED. HOUSING
ASSOCIATIONS. YEAH 20% ASSEMBLY
MEMBER BONTA A DOCTOR ROMANS
YOU INDICATED THAT THERE WAS A
TWO PERCENT- A SOCIAL HOUSING
RATE IN IN. IN SPAIN- LARGELY
BECAUSE OF THE AFFORDABLE OWNER
OCCUPIED HOUSING THAT HAD BEEN
DEVELOPED OVER TIME CANYOU
SHARE A LITTLE BIT MORE THE
COMPONENTS OF THE AFFORDABLE
OWNER OCCUPIED HOUSING AT DR
AMONG YOU ALSO MENTIONED THAT
AS A KEY COMPONENT OF THE
PORTFOLIO SO. IF YOU COULD
COMMENT ON ON THAT COMPONENT OF
YOUR PORTFOLIOS. YEAH SURE SO
WHY. URING THE FIRST CAN YOU
HEAR ME YEAH. YEAH RIGHT SO-
ALL RIGHT SO. WAS THAT THE-
AFFORDABLE OWNERSHIP MODEL WAS
TEMPORARILY- SO IT WAS REALLY
RESTRICTED JUST FOR A CERTAIN
PERIOD OF TIME. SO AFTER THESE
TIME WHEN BONNIE THE UNITS WILL
BE DEREGULATED AGREED RESULTS
RESTS. THAT MEANS THAT MOST OF
THE UNIT IS. NOT TO SAY ALL OF
THEM ARE REALLY IN THE FREE
MARKET AND COULD NOT BE
CONSIDERED AFFORDABLE HOUSING
ANYMORE. THAT'S WHY WE DON'T
HAVE WE WILL HAVE NO AFFORDABLE
LEFT BESIDES THE VERY LITTLE
PORTION OF THE POLITICAL
PARTIES HAVE KEPT AS MEDICAL
HOUSE. REALLY LEARNING ALSO
YEAH. IN THE NINETEEN SIXTIES
SEVENTIES AND UNIT NINETEEN
EIGHTIES SOME. ONE OF THE LOCAL
LIKE HOUSING COMMENTED FOR
ROUGHLY 50% OR EVEN WORE OFF
FROM. THE HOUSING PRODUCTION
HOUSING ASSOCIATIONS THIS
CHANGE IN THE NINETEEN NINETIES
WHEN ARRANGED BY SCHEME WAS
INTRODUCED THOSE RAISED BY
APARTMENTS ACTUALLY HAVE
REPLACED THE FORMER WILL
PROVIDE. HOUSING ALL TOLD-
TODAY- IT IS STILL RT NEWS
REPORTING THAT ROUGHLY 50% ALSO
HIS SON RAISED BY SOME 5210% IS
OWNED BY AND IS THE RACES-
RANGED WITHHOLDS OF OPTION TO
BUY. A ROUGHLY 30% OF
HOUSEHOLDS WOULD HAVE ARRANGED
BY APARTMENT WE'LL JUST TAKE IT
OFF STUDENT BY THE APARTMENT.
ALSO OBTAIN USUAL. SAN PERCENT
THE FIRST STATE IN THE RIGHT
HOMES. GOD WILL BE WAS. HOUSE
DECISIONS I SO THE ACTUAL-
DIFFER. HALF AND MANY RANDOM
POP INS AS WELL. BECAUSE RUN.
THEY HAD A ADULT. WITH A- THIS
EVEN- S. AS IS A DISCOUNT RATE
IN. IN THE LONG TERM ONLY USED
ESSENTIAL TO OWN A. THANK YOU.
ANY OTHER QUESTIONS FROM MY
COLLEAGUES. WELL THANK YOU VERY
MUCH- FOR YOUR INFORMATIVE WORK
I'M SORRY ABOUT THE TECH
TECHNICAL CHALLENGES WORKSHEET
SORT OF LUCKY WE HAVE POWER
HERE RIGHT NOW IN THIS ROOM I
THINK WE WERE THE ONLY ONES IN
OAKLAND HAVE POWER AT THE
MOMENT- BUT I WON I APPRECIATE-
THE PRESENTATIONS. AND WE ARE
NOW GOING TO MOVE INTO- THE
PUBLIC- COMMENT SECTION OF THIS
MEETING- AS WE PROCEED WITH THE
WITNESSES AND PUBLIC COMMENT AS
STATED AT THE BEGINNING HEARING
ON TO MAKE SURE EVERYONE
UNDERSTANDS OF THE ASSEMBLY HAS
RULES TO ENSURE WE MAINTAIN
ORDERED RUN EFFICIENT. AND FAIR
HEARING WE APPLY THESE RULES TO
ALL PEOPLE WHO ARE
PARTICIPATING IN OUR
PROCEEDINGS AND IN ORDER TO
FACILITATE. THE GOAL HEARING AS
MUCH FROM THE PUBLIC WITHIN THE
LIMITS OF OUR TIME WE WILL NOT
PERMIT CONDUCT THAT DISRUPTS TO
SERBS OR OTHERWISE IMPEDES THE
ORDERLY CONDUCT OF LEGISLATIVE
PROCEEDINGS WILL NOT ACCEPT
DISRUPTIVE BEHAVIOR BEHAVIOR
THAT INCITES OR THREATENS
VIOLENCE EVEN VEILED THREATS.
PLEASE BE AWARE THAT VIOLATIONS
OF THESE RULES MOVIE SUBJECT
YOU TO REMOVE REMOVE ALL OUR
OTHER ENFORCEMENT PROCESS SEES-
SO WE'RE NOW GOING TO HAVE
PUBLIC COMMENT I BELIEVE WE
HAVE UNTIL ABOUT TWELVE THIRTY
FOR PUBLIC COMMENT RESTING
FOLKS TO- EACH SPEAKER TO-
REDUCED OUR COMMENTS. ONE
MINUTE OR LESS. I WILL START
OFF WITH- FOLKS IN THE ROOM IN
A FOLKS WANT TO. HAVE PUBLIC
PROVIDE PUBLIC COMMENT PLEASE.
COME DOWN HERE- AND FORMALIZED-
OUT THIS WAY- ALL PUBLIC
COMMENTS NEED TO BE FOCUSED ON
SOCIAL HOUSING. COMMENTS AND
OTHER ISSUES WILL BE RULED OUT
OF ORDER. COMMENTERS WHO IMPEDE
THE ORDERLY CONDUCT OF THIS
MEETING BY- ANY DISRUPTIONS
WILL BE AGAIN REMOVED. AND IF
YOU'D LIKE TO MAKE COMMENTS-
IT'S THROUGH REMOTE TESTIMONY-
THAT PHONE NUMBER IS. EIGHT
SEVEN SEVEN SIX NINE TWO EIGHT
NINE FIVE SEVEN. AND USE THE
PUBLIC ACCESS CODE. ONE THREE
ONE FIVE ONE EIGHT FIVE ZERO.
AND THAT INFORMATION AGAIN CAN
BE FOUND. AT W. W. W. DOT
ASSEMBLY DOT CA DOT GOV FORWARD
SLASH TODAY'S EVENTS. AND WITH
THAT AGAIN PLEASE LEAVE
COMMENTS TWO ONE MINUTE OR LESS
NAME IDENTIFYING ORGANIZATION
AND THE COMMENT THAT YOU LIKE
TO PROVIDE AND WE ARE VERY
EXCITED TO HEAR. FROM THE
PUBLIC ABOUT SOCIAL HOUSING SO
WITH THAT. OUR FIRST SPEAKER.
HI MY NAME IS SONNY TRAVIS OF
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF YES IN MY
BACKYARD AND I AM SO EXCITED
THAT THIS COMMITTEE EVEN EXISTS
IT REALLY FEELS LIKE ONLY A
COUPLE YEARS AGO. THE IDEA OF
SOCIAL HOUSING WAS INEXORABLY
CONNECTED TO PUBLIC HOUSING AND
EVERYBODY AS SOON THE PUBLIC
HOUSING FAILED SO I'M SO GLAD
THAT WE HAVE PRESENTATIONS
FROM- YOU KNOW OPERATORS OF
EXISTING PUBLIC HOUSING AND
SOCIAL HOUSING AND- AND
PROFESSORS. YOU KNOW LETTING
EVERYONE KNOW THAT SOCIAL
HOUSING IS NOT A FAILURE THAT
IT'S POSSIBLE- THAT ALL WE NEED
IS YOU KNOW THE MONEY TO DO IT
IN THE POLITICAL WELL AND THANK
YOU SO MUCH FOR PROVIDING THAT.
THANK YOU SONYA. OUR NEXT
SPEAKER. HI GOOD AFTERNOON
HONORABLE CHAIRMAN MEMBERS AMY
HINES SHAIKH WITH WILDCAT
CONSULTING REPRESENTING THE
CALIFORNIA COMMUNITY LAND TRUST
NETWORK WE WISH TO ALIGN OUR
REMARKS WITH THE PUBLIC
ADVOCATES IN THE LETTER THAT
WAS SENT TO YOU WITH EIGHTY
FIVE SIGNATORY ORGANIZATIONS-
SPEAKING IN GREAT SUPPORT OF
PUBLIC HOUSING. SOCIAL HOUSING
RATHER AND- WE WOULD ALSO LIKE
TO HIGHLIGHT THE FACT THAT
COMMUNITY LAND TRUST AS THEY
EXIST TODAY AND THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA OF A FIELD MANY OF
THE ELEMENTS OF SOCIAL HOUSING
AS DEFINED IN THE SOCIAL
HOUSING BILL I IS D.
COMMODIFIED HOUSING MEANING
IT'S EITHER PUBLICLY OR
COOPERATIVELY OWNED OR OWNED BY
A QUALIFIED COMMUNITY BASED
NONPROFIT LIKE A COMMUNITY LAND
TRUST. IT'S A VEHICLE AVAILABLE
AT AFFORDABLE COST TO RESIDENTS
OF ALL INCOME LEVELS IS THE IS
THE ONE ITEM THAT WE LIKE TO
HIGHLIGHT THAT WE'RE NOT ABLE
TO COMPLETELY FILL MOSTLY DUE
TO FINANCING SO- THAT IS
ACTUALLY A REALLY WONDERFUL
POINT THAT WAS MADE BY MONDAY
MULTIPLE SPEAKERS ABOUT THE
NEED FOR PUBLIC BANKS WE LOVE
PUBLIC BANKS AND PUBLIC
THINKING- IT IS PERMANENTLY
AFFORDABLE AND IT PROVIDES
RESIDENTS WITH THE RIGHT TO
PARTICIPATE DEMOCRATICALLY SELF
WE VERY MUCH APPRECIATE YOU AND
THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR HAVING
THIS HEARING THANK YOU AND
APPRECIATE THE LETTER LOOKING
FOR TO WORKING WITH YOU ALL.
NEXT BIGGER PLEASE. THANK YOU
MADAM CHAIRMAN OF THE COMMITTEE
JEREMY SMITH HERE ON BEHALF OF
THE STATE BUILDING AND
CONSTRUCTION TRADES COUNCIL-
WE'RE HERE BECAUSE WE WANT TO
BE PART OF THE SOLUTION- THIS
HEARING A SHOWS ALL POSSIBLE
WAY THE WAY THOSE WORK IN THE
PAST BUT IMPORTANTLY WE HEARD
ABOUT HOW THE HOUSING IS BUILT
IS AS IMPORTANT AS FUNDING
LOCATION DESIGN. HOW DOES BILL
IS WHY I'M HERE TODAY BUILDING
HOUSING THE LAST LIKE THOSE
PROJECTS HE SAW THE NINETEEN
THIRTIES- THEY'RE STILL UTILIZE
TODAY'S BEST DONE BY SKILLED
AND TRAINED WORKFORCE THAT IS
LOCALLY BASED. AND TRAIN
INSTEAD APPROACH CALIFORNIA
PRESSURE PROGRAMS WE'RE FIRM
BELIEVERS. THAT PROVIDING JOB
OPPORTUNITIES AND THINKING
ABOUT HOW WORKERS ARE TREATED
AND PAID ON THESE PROJECTS IS
IMPORTANT UNTANGLING THE KNOT
OF PROVIDING HOUSING. TO THOSE
WHO GOT MOST. WE FOUND HOWEVER
IS THE PROFIT MOTIVE. ON MIXED
USE AND AFFORDABLE PROJECTS
OFTEN STANDS IN OPPOSITION TO
DECISIONS ABOUT HOW WORKERS
ACTUALLY BUILDING THE HOUSING.
ARE TREATED. YOU ALL HEARD
RESIDENT ROB HUNTER YOUR LOCAL
BLUE TRADE UNION LEADERS ABOUT
HOW IMPORTANT ISSUE THE TEAM TO
WORKERS ON THESE PROJECTS
PERHAPS TAKING PART. OR ALL OF
THE PROFIT MOTIVE OUT OF THE
PROCESS IS ONE WITH A FULL ONE
WAY FORWARD. TO SOLVING THE
CRISIS WE ARE AN- EXTINGUISHER
ME APPRECIATE YOU FOR COMING
HERE AND- WE WILL BE HEARING
MORE FROM YOU ALL AND OTHER
HEARINGS. SO WE LOOK FORWARD TO
THAT NEXT BIGGER PLEASE. THANK
YOU ASSEMBLY MEMBERS FOR
CONVENING THIS CONVERSATION. MY
NAME'S LEO GOLDBERG I'M CO
DIRECTOR WITH THE CALIFORNIA
FEEL T. NETWORK THAT'S CAMINO
INTEREST NETWORK. AND I WANNA
LIFT UP THAT CALIFORNIA.
CHAMAELEONTIS STEWARD. OVER
SIXTEEN HUNDRED UNITS OF
PERMANENTLY AFFORDABLE.
DEMOCRATICALLY CONTROLLED
HOUSING THAT WE SEE AS GREAT.
EXAMPLES OF SOCIAL HOUSING IN
EFFECT TODAY WITHIN. A FEW
MILES FROM HERE WE HAVE FOR
CAMINO ENTRUSTED STORED.
HUNDREDS OF UNITS OF. SOCIAL
HOUSING TODAY. AND THERE'S
SEVERAL THINGS THAT I THINK THE
SELECT COMMITTEE CAN LOOK AT
TO. EXPAND SOCIAL HOUSING STOCK
IN GENERAL IN CAMINO ENTERS
HOUSING STOCK. AKE KILLER.
REALLY AFFORDABLE HOUSING. AND
TO SUPPORTING- TEN OPPORTUNITY
TO PURCHASE ORDINANCES TO
TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE AND
ACQUISITIONS SO THANKS AGAIN
FOR THIS OPPORTUNITY. THANK YOU
APPRECIATE IT. NEXT BIGGER
PLACE. A GOOD AFTERNOON CHAIR
WORKS AND MEMBERS ON THIS FROM
MOST LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL PUBLIC
ADVOCATES AS WAS MENTIONED
EARLIER- WE HAD SUBMITTED A
LETTER WITH OVER EIGHTY FIVE
THE ORGANIZATIONS FROM THE
STATE- FIRST OF ALL THIS ONE
EXPRESS OUR EXCITEMENT THAT
THIS A SELECT COMMITTEE WAS PUT
TOGETHER AND VERY GLAD TO BEARD
PRESENT AT THIS HEARING A LOT
OF GREAT INFORMATION OVER
LOOKING FORWARD TO THE FUTURE
HEARINGS- JUST A HIGHLIGHT YOU
KNOW AS EXPRESS OUR LETTER WE
SEE SOCIAL HOUSING IS TO
COMMODIFIED HOUSING. PUTTING
THE NEEDS OF PEOPLE FIRST- BUT
ALSO WHAT I WANT TO HIGHLIGHT
THAT IN ADDITION TO PRODUCTION
IT ALSO INCLUDES OF COURSE
ACQUISITION AND PRESERVATION OF
EXISTING HOUSING STOCK OF
SOCIAL HOUSING SO WE LOOK FOR
TO CONTINUE THE CONVERSATION
WE'VE ALREADY BEEN IN CONTACT
WITH SOME OF YOUR STAFF AND
LOOK FORWARD TO CONTINUING TO
ENGAGE IN THE CONVERSATION
THANK YOU THANK YOU APPRECIATE
YOU HAVE AG SEEM. NEXT BIGGER
PLEASE. ALOHA COMMITTEE CHAIR
MEMBERS MY NAME'S MITCHELL
BATTLE I WORK FOR THE IRON
WORKERS LOCAL ONE EIGHTEEN I
FELT REALLY WHAT IT COMES DOWN
TO IS THAT- AFFORDABLE HOUSING
AND FAIR WAGES ARE NOT MUTUALLY
EXCLUSIVE RIGHT WE TALK A LOT
ABOUT HOW TO BETTER SERVE OUR
COMMUNITIES- WE SHOULDN'T SEEK
TO SOLVE THE HOUSING CRISIS ON
THE BACKS OF THE PEOPLE
CONSTRUCTING THE HOUSES AND SO
WE'RE REALLY JUST HERE ACTUALLY
IN THE SENTIMENTS OF THE STATE
BUILDING TRADES- WE WANT TO
WORK TOGETHER WITH YOU GUYS AND
MAKE SURE THAT THAT SKILLED AND
TRAINED WORKFORCE LANGUAGES- IN
THERE BECAUSE THAT PROVIDES THE
OPPORTUNITY IN THE FRAMEWORK.
TO GET PEOPLE OUT OF OUT OF
THESE SITUATIONS THAT HAVE LED
THEM TO NEED PUBLIC ASSISTANCE
IN THE FIRST PLACE THANK YOU
AND HOPE TO WORK WITH YOU GUYS
THANK YOU VERY MUCH APPRECIATED.
NEXT BIGGER PLACE. GOOD
AFTERNOON AUDIBLE CHAIRMAN AND
MEMBERS MY NAME IS MIKE WESTON
I REPRESENT THE INTERNATIONAL
UNION OF PAINTERS AND ALLIED
TRADES. IN MANY OF THE HEARINGS
AND TESTIMONY THAT I'VE
WITNESSED- IT IS RELATED TO
AFFORDABLE HOUSING IS STATED IT
JUST DOESN'T PENCIL OUT TO
PROVIDE LABOR PROTECTIONS FOR
THE PEOPLE BUILDING THE HOUSING
SO I SUGGESTED THAT WE SHARPEN
OUR PENCILS. ON THE FRONT END
AND LIMIT THE AMOUNT OF PROFIT
THAT THE AFFORDABLE HOUSING
DEVELOPERS THE ARCHITECTS AND
ENGINEERS CAN PULL OUT OF A
PROJECT BEFORE IT EVEN HITS-
THE FIELD- SECONDLY WHEN YOU'RE
TALKING ABOUT PROJECTS THAT ARE
BUILT TO LAST WHY NOT CONSIDER
THOSE MEN AND WOMEN WHO ARE
GRADUATES OF STATE RECOGNIZED
APPRENTICESHIP PROGRAMS. WHO
ARE TRAINED TO GET THE WORK
DONE CORRECTLY ON TIME AND ON
BUDGET WITH THE FEWEST AMOUNT
OF PEOPLE AND FINALLY YOU CAN'T
BUILD YOUR WAY OUT OF THE
HOUSING CRISIS BY PAYING
POVERTY WAGES. AND A LOT OF
CASES THIS WORK IS BEING DONE
BY PEOPLE IN THE UNDERGROUND
ECONOMY WHO ARE NOT EVEN PAYING
TAXES HERE IN CALIFORNIA THANK
YOU FOR YOUR TIME I APPRECIATE
YOUR TESTIMONY THANK YOU. GOOD
AFTERNOON MY NAME'S DEREK SAY
TORN I LIVE OAKLAND A MEMBER OF
EAST BAY FOR EVERYONE- I AND-
JUST WANTED TO CONGRATULATE
COMMITTEE ON. CONVENE THIS IS A
REALLY IMPORTANT TOPIC. I JUST
WANT TO EMPHASIZE IN ADDITION
TO THE DISCUSSIONS OF
ACQUISITION OF OUR EXISTING
FILTERED APARTMENTS AND HOMES.
I REALLY THINK THE PRODUCTION
OF NEW HOUSINGIS SO IMPORTANT
WE HAVE A SHORTAGE OF ONE POINT
TWO MILLION HOMES IN CALIFORNIA
FOR LOW INCOME PEOPLE. AND WE
CAN'T SOLVE THAT PROBLEM
WITHOUT DEVELOPING NEW
CONSTRUCTION AND WE THAT'S
THAT'S A BIG CHALLENGE WE NEED
TO GET IN THE RIGHT LOCATIONS
AS AS A MEMBER BONTA. MENTIONED
WE NEED TO MAKE IT GREEN AND WE
NEED TO MAKE SURE THAT WE ARE
MIXING AS WE HAVE LOW AND
MODERATE INCOME PEOPLE
TOGETHER- AND ON THAT I JUST
REALLY HOPE THAT THE COMMITTEE
LOOK HARD AT WAYS THAT WE CAN.
BEND THE COST CURVE FOR- THIS
SORT OF HOUSING. IN WAY THAT
DOESN'T BACK PUT THAT THAT COST
ON. THE END USER THE TENANTS.
BUT ALSO NOT ON THE PEOPLE WHO
BILL THAT WE GOT TO FIGURE OUT
HOW WE CAN DO THAT TOGETHER-
AND THEN WITH THE PROCESS THE
WITH A POLICY DESIGNED. THANK
YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR
YOUR COMMENTS. NEXT BIGGER
PLEASE. HELLO MY NAME KING I
HAVE IN THE SAN DISTRICT AND
I'M THANKFUL THAT THIS CAN
BECAUSE THEY AND ALL FOR ALL OF
THE GREAT CUSTOMER WITH HER
FROM BOTH IN THE US AND AROUND
THE WORLD- I HOPE GOING FORWARD
THAT YOU'LL LOOK AT
OPPORTUNITIES TO INCLUDE PEOPLE
FROM OTHER COUNTRIES AS WELL
COUNTRIES WHERE THEY ARE
ACTUALLY ANALOGUES MORE MORE
SPECIFIC ANALYST AT UNITED
STATES PLACES LIKE TAIWAN
WHERE. THEY ARE VERY RAPIDLY
BUILDING AT SUCH A HOUSING FROM
A VERY SMALL BASE- ALSO I HOPE
THAT YOU'LL LOOK AT WAYS TO
EMPLOY TECHNOLOGIES THAT CAN
HELP REDUCE COSTS AS WELL AS
ADVANCED- OTHER ASSOCIATED
GOALS THINGS LIKE PASSIVE HOUSE
TO REDUCE OUR ENERGY USAGE OR
MODULAR CONSTRUCTION AND COST
THEM THE TIMBER TO HELP REDUCE.
COSTS BASICALLY FIND A WAY TO-
IN THE PAST OF BUILDING SO
HOUSING ALSO. AT DEMAND. FOR
TECHNOLOGY THAT CAN IMPROVE.
THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK YOU
FOR THAT TESTIMONY NEXT BIGGER
PLACE. HI ON CAMERA WITH EAST
BAY FOR EVERYONE- I REALLY
APPRECIATE THE HISTORY AND
MODELS PRESENT HERE TODAY-
WE'RE EXCITED BY THE
POSSIBILITIES OF CALIFORNIA
ITSELF PROVIDING EXPERTISE TO
CITIES AND SCHOOL DISTRICTS TO
DEVELOP BUILD AND DEVELOP
HOUSING- I MEAN WE HAVE A LONG
WAY TO GO TO GET TO THE
AUSTRIAN MODEL BUT- WE HAVE TO
START SOMEWHERE SO. THANK YOU
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. HI THERE
MY NAME IS MARK FOLLOW ON WITH-
CALIFORNIA COMMON GROUND.
SILICON VALLEY DSA AND OTHER
ORGANIZATIONS. I WOULD JUST
LIKE TO SAY I'M VERY HAPPY WERE
WE'RE DISCUSSING IS A LEARNING
FROM WHAT WORKS AT A WORLD
SCALE AT THE SKILL WE NEED.
WE'RE IN A HUGE SHORTAGE AND
HOUSING AFFORDABILITY AWFUL
INTO- TO REALLY. SPEND ANYTHING
WE NEED SCALE THAT IS GOING TO
ACTUALLY AFFECT THE EVERY
HOUSING WE HAVE THERE IS AS AS
A BUFFER STOCK. IN JUST TO.
HIGHLIGHT ONE THREAD YOU KNOW I
THINK WHAT YOU SEE WORK HERE IS
IT'S YOU HAVE TO AVOID SHORT
TERMISM OF YOU KNOW I THINK
THIS OF. ANY SORT OF ASSET
THAT. FLOWS AWAY FROM FROM
CONTROL OF AFFORDABLE ENDS. TO
PRIVATE AND- AND- I THINK
BUILDING A VIRTUOUS CYCLE OF
INSTITUTIONS TO TRY TO GROW
GROW CAPACITY. AND NOT JUST
HAVE LIKE A LINE ITEM IN EIGHT
CD I THINK HAVING INSTITUTIONS
AND AGENCIES WHICH HAVE
INDEPENDENT. POWER BEHIND THEM
IS VERY POWERFUL. AND YOUR TO
LEVERAGE THE LAND SUBSIDY THAT
THAT THAT THIS ALL COMES FROM
TO MAKE YOUR TOP THANK YOU VERY
MUCH FOR TESTIMONY. NEXT BIGGER
PLACE. YES GOOD AFTERNOON
CHAIRMAN. MY NAME IS JORDAN
CRIMES I MAY SAN MATTEO
RESIDENT AND A LEAD MEMBER OF
PENINSULA FOR EVERYONE- WE'RE
A- GRASSROOTS HOUSING ADVOCACY
GROUP FROM DALY CITY TO
SUNNYVALE- AND REALLY JUST HERE
TO SHARE OUR EXCITEMENT- AND
ELATION THAT THIS COMMITTEE.
EVEN EXISTS- THAT WE ARE YOU
KNOW TALKING ABOUT SOCIAL
HOUSING THAT WE COULD- VERY
HOPEFULLY SEE AND SEE IN MY
LIFETIME AND POTENTIALLY MY
CHILDREN'S LIFETIMES- THIS IS
THIS IS NOT JUST- AND A FIFTY.
AND EFFICIENT METHOD OF HOUSING
CREATION BUT BUT A MORAL
IMPERATIVE- I REALLY WANNA
HIGHLIGHT SOME OF THE COMMENTS
MADE EARLIER IN THE HEARING
SPECIFICALLY AROUND LOCATION-
WE HAVE SO MANY- TRULY AFFLUENT
HYPER AFFLUENT AREAS AND- IN
THE BAY AREA. THAT ARE YOU
KNOW. PERFECT EXAMPLES OF
SUBURBAN SPRAWL THAT WOULD BE-
JUST JUST WONDERFUL TO REBUILD
AROUND SOCIAL HOUSING- WE NEED
TO DO THAT THIS IS A MORAL
IMPERATIVE AND I THANK YOU FOR
YOUR TIME. THANK YOU VERY MUCH
YOU GUYS ARE DOING A GOOD JOB
KEEPING IT ONE MINUTE. NEXT
GOOD AFTERNOON MY NAME IS JIM
HUGH I'M A CO DIRECTOR OF THE
UNIVERSAL AND COMPULSORY- I
WANT TO ECHO PREVIOUS
STATEMENTS ENSURING DEEP
APPRECIATION FOR THE COMMITTEE
ARE PUSHING THIS IDEA BOARD
THAT HAS THE POTENTIAL TO
REALLY HAVE A POSITIVE
TRANSFORMATIVE IMPACT ON THE
HOUSING CRISIS IN CALIFORNIA I
ALSO WANT TO STATE MY SUPPORT
FOR PARTICULARLY PURSUING MIXED
INCOME SOCIAL HOUSING- SINCE
FIFTEENTH NOT THE SOCIAL
PROGRAMS THAT IF YOU ENSURE
THAT YOU ARE BEING INCLUSIVE OF
BUT NOT EXCLUSIVE TO VERY POOR
CALIFORNIANS YOU AVOID
SEGMENTATION STIGMATIZATION-
AND ALSO HELP TO CREATE A MORE
SUSTAINABLE PROGRAM BOTH
POLITICALLY AND FINANCIALLY.
THANK YOU THANK YOU. NEXT AT
THIS ARE SPEAKER IN THE ROOM
AND THEN WE'LL GO TO REMOTE
TESTIMONY. I THANK YOU VERY
MUCH FOR FORMING THIS
COMMITTEE- MY NAME IS LISA
JOHNSON I AM WITH THE IN THE
ASSOCIATION UNITED RICHMOND
HOUSING PROVIDERS. AND I'M JUST
HERE TO SAY THAT THERE ARE MANY
MONPA HOUSING PROVIDERS RIGHT
NOW WHO ARE REALLY STRUGGLING.
AND HAVE A LOT OF WONDERFUL
IDEAS OUR WANT TO EMBRACE MANY
OF THE CONCEPTS DISCUSSED HERE
TODAY. HAVE LOTS OF LOTS OF
IDEAS ON VOUCHER PROGRAMS AND
HOW TO STIMULATE THAT. THERE
ARE MANY CHALLENGES THAT
THEY'RE FACING WITH COVERT
NINETEEN AND WITH INEQUITIES IN
RENT CONTROL POLICIES
THROUGHOUT THE STATE IN VARIOUS
CITIES. AND SO WE'D LIKE TO
HAVE A VOICE AT THAT TABLE. WE
DON'T FEEL WE'RE BEING
REPRESENTED BY MANY OF THE
LARGER ORGANIZATIONS AND SO I
WOULD REALLY LOVE IT. FIND SOME
MECHANISM FOR GROUPS LIKE A OR
H. P. AND IT TOGETHER IN
OAKLAND. TO ACTUALLY
PARTICIPATE IN THIS PROCESS
THANK YOU THANK YOU VERY MUCH
APPRECIATE THAT- AND WITH THAT
WE WILL GO TO- REMOTE
TESTIMONY. OPERATOR DO WE HAVE
ANYONE IN THE QUEUE REMOTELY.
IT THERE ANY. AND ALSO IF YOU
WISH TO DISCUSS ON THE CALL
PRESS ONE AND THE. ZERO ONCE
AGAIN IF YOU'RE JUST ON CALL
UNIVERSE ONE AT THE. ZERO SB
CURRENTLY HAVE FIFTY INITIATIVE-
THEY ARE VERY MINE IT IS MINE
THERE IS. MICHAEL YOUR LINE IS
OPEN BECAUSE- AM I LYING
THIRTIES NINETY HER. YES WE
HAVING PROBLEM CALLING SERVICES
I'VE BEEN HAVING MAJOR BECAUSE
FEATURES. AND I INTO WITH A
FULL COMMUNITY I WANT TO MAKE
SURE IN THE RIGHT FOR ME. HELLO.
STATION IN YOUR. OUR LOCAL IN
YOUR LIVING COMMENT TO THE FULL
THIRTY AND I COMING BACK THAT
YOU WE HAVE NOT I'D GO YOU TO
PLAY BETTER YOU SHOULD BE CUT
FROM. USUALLY PEOPLE TO CALL
FOR YOU SHOULD OFFER DISH AND
THE IN A- PEOPLE WERE ON TO GET
A FOR THE TODAY ON. AND I THINK
IT'S THREE INTO AND HOW AT A
POWER OUT THERE AND HE WILL NOW
WANT TO SEEK OF THE HOUSE STOCK
WE WANT YOU CAN KEEP THE ON WE
LOVE YOU SEE WITH THE WITH A
COUPLE SCHOOL ARE CRUMBLING AND
NOW YOU SEE YOU WANT CONTROL
HOW STOCK. WE NEED PEOPLE TO
GET BACK IN ORDER TO QUALIFY
FOR HOUSING BECAUSE EVEN A REAL
ISSUES HOW RIGHT NOW. NOT
ANYWAY REFORM THE ROLE I FIVE
PEOPLE WHO ARE ALL BEING
OSTRACIZED AND LEFT OUT OF THE
CONVERSATION GO TO P. THAT IS
ONE MINUTE. NEXT NEXT NEXT
PLEASE OPERATOR. NEXT BIGGER
PLACE. FINE THIRTY EIGHT YOUR
LINE IS OPEN PLEASE GO AHEAD.
GOOD AFTERNOON MY NAME IS LOST
TO THE SCENE AND SPEAKING ON
BEHALF OF THE SERVICES OF ANY
GRASS- WE SUPPORT PUBLIC
HOUSING FOR ALL WITHIN THE
FRAMEWORK AS A HOUSING AND WE
ARE HOPEFUL TO SEE EASIER. MORE
FOR A STATE OR FEDERALLY
HOUSING IT WAS GREAT TO SEE OUR
GUYS IS PRETTY LIMITATION ON
THE MILITANTS ASKING THE PUBLIC
HOUSING. I HEAR THEM SAY THAT
WE HAVE JUST LAST YEAR ALTHOUGH
I OUT TO YOU TO DECIDE HOUSING
ON ARTICLE THIRTY WILL THAT HAS
THE CASE AND WE'RE EAGER TO SEE
THE STATE BELOW AND HELPING
FUND UNIFIL FOR ALL YOU NEED.
TO THANK YOU. MY OKAY. GOOD
AFTERNOON NAME IS ALLEY ARE AND
SO TO WORK A LITTLE AND PUBLIC
NEWS THE OVER A FEW FEW YEAR
VIA HOW ARE GOING THIS AND I AM
A LOT OF TWENTY TWENTY I REALLY
WANT TO MAKE THE COMING
UNDERSTAND PUBLIC HOUSE THAT IS
HOME BY GOVERNMENT BY PEOPLE IS
IMPORTANT IN A LOT OF TIME
LITTLE THE- THE DEFINITION WILL
CALL UP BY FOR GROUPS SO
HOUSING PUBLIC HEALTH
PARTICULARLY IMPORTANT TO. A
FILE YOU CAN MAKE SURE THAT
EVERY GETS PROBABLY REGARDLESS
OF THEIR YOU KNOW AND HOLDING
TO KEEP RIGHTS THE SUPER
IMPORTANT UNDERSTAND THAT AND
WE SEE THAT YOU KNOW FORTY THAT-
PUBLIC HAS NOT BEEN
CONVERSATION I REALLY NEED TO
BE AND IF I WANT TO IMPRESS
UPON AT THE PUMP HOW THE AND
PER- THE KIND LITTLE TO SUPER
AND SHOULD WE FOCUS ON- DURING
THE FROM WORK THANK YOU. FOR
THANK YOU NEXT CALLER. MY
TWENTY THREE YEAR IS OPEN
PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD MORNING
AFTER NOW I'M THE MODERATE
RIGHT UNITED AND WARNED THEM
FOR THE- DEMOCRATIC COUNCIL.
ELECTIONS IS VERY UP TO THE
COURT DOWN OF THE- A LITTLE THE
RAMP GOT. BUT UNTIL WE SOLVE
THE WHETHER DID IT WELL TO GET
OUT OF THE CAR OR NOT WE NEED
TO SPEAK PRINT. OF WRITERS AS
WELL AND WE'VE GOT A SERIES
PROBLEM WITH WITH THE A LITTLE
BIT OUT OF HOW THE DOCK TO WITH
EIGHTY EIGHT TWO. EXACTLY RIGHT
THAT IT PERCENT ANNUALLY AND WE
ARE ACROSS OFFERING THAT RIGHT
NOW WITH THE CPR. WE HAVE WHERE.
I'M NOT GETTING ANYWHERE HAVE
SAID WHEN INCREASES SO THIS IS
A BIT PROBLEM BECAUSE THAT
HAPPENS ON. I DON'T KNOW TO SEE
LITTLE BIT THE MEASURE EARLIER
THEIR A CAR. IN ASKING BY. WE
DO HAVE A CARD. FOUR BECAUSE
CAR MANAGER. AND NOW. THAT OWN.
THE THAT ARE AVAILABLE. HAVE A
WAVE MINUTE LATER TOMORROW
RIGHT AND MARKET RATE IN THE
EASILY WHERE. FOR A- YOUR RATE
AND- SO WE HAVE TO ADDRESS THAT.
LACK OF. WITH VERY CORE TO. A
COPPER. BECAUSE. ED VERY MUCH
THANK YOU. HOUSING AUTHORITY.
ON YOU CAN OR HOUSING TO BILL
STATE PUBLIC THE HIS PUBLIC HOW
CONSTRUCTION HI ALZHEIMER'S
EVELYN CREATE HE PUBLIC
CONSTRUCTION APARTMENT THAT
THAT ABILITY BUILD LOW COST
HIGH QUALITY ENVIRONMENTALLY
PUBLIC HOUSING AT SCALE USING
UNITS WE NEED TO ENSURE THAT
PUBLIC HOUSING BILLS WHY
COULDN'T RURAL AREAS THE
RESEARCHERS ARE ALL SHE. ALSO
HE TOLD ME TO TRY TO
CONSTRUCTION USE TO MAKE SURE
CREDIT CONSTRUCTION CORRECT OR.
FINALLY HOW SHOULD INCLUDE
THREE MORE HOW WELL- AWFUL HOME
INTO THANK YOU. YOU VERY MUCH
NEXT COLOR. MINDFULLY YEAR OVER
PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD AFTERNOON
EVERYONE MY NAME TO THE BOARD
CURRENTLY OF THE- DEMOCRAT OF
THE- I DON'T THINK ALL THE
HEARING I WANT TO EMPHASIZE OR
OR- OR WHICH IS ALSO HOW THE-
ON EMERGING BUILDING THE STATE
DEPENDENT ON CONTRACT OF
MEANING THAT THE BORDER ALL-
AND WELL. AS AS OF. TEN THAT
COULD BE THE WORK OF THE
COMMUNITY AND WORKING WITH YOU
ALL. TODAY. THANK YOU VERY MUCH
NEXT A NEXT A WITNESS PLEASE.
ONE FORTY TWO YOUR LINE IS OPEN
PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD AFTERNOON
MY NAME IS RUNNING WAY UNDER
THE STATE BY CAMPAIGN
COORDINATOR WILL COMMUNITY
GROUP CASE WE LINE OUR COMMENTS
ON THE LETTERS AND ABOUT EIGHTY
BY ORGANIZATIONS IN SUPPORT OF
A SOCIAL JUSTICE OKAY SOCIAL
HOUSING ECOSYSTEM CALIFORNIA SH
ONE THING THAT HAPPENED A FEW
DAYS INFORMED EFFORTS. BY THE
PHILIPPINE ON THE SILICON
VALLEY MINISTER ACTUALLY
HAPPENING THE REFERENCES TO THE
ROLE OF PRESERVATION OF
AFFORDABLE HOUSING THROUGH
CERTAINLY IS AN IDEA WHOSE TIME
HAS COME I'M GOING STRONGEST OF-
WE GONNA PULL ASKIA AND SHE-
ILLEGAL HOUSING. HE COUNTY
PEOPLE AFFORDABLE OFFICE IN THE
MARKET AND- CONTROLLED OUR-
ACOSTA FAILURES- THAT HAVE MORE
AND HOW HOW ARE YOU ARE HIGHLY
GROWING WE SOCIAL HOUSING. AND
A ABOUT HIM ARE TO CONVERT.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. GIVE YOUR
TO NOT NEXT SPEAKER. NINE
THIRTY THREE YOUR LIFE IS OPEN
ACCOUNT. AND SHERMAN MENTIONED
A LOT. NAME WE NEED A THREE ARE
NOT ONLY SITTING IN AN ARTICLE
HOW TO TAKE MORE. FROM OUR-
FULL YOUR FOR TO THE MORE IN.
SHE CONSTRUCTION OF IS THAT OF
ACTUAL. SINGLE FAMILY HOME. OR
RETIREMENT HOW DO SOLVE
INEQUALITY IS AN EQUITY ISSUE.
SO I WENT BACK SAID. WE ARE
BRIGHTER CALIFORNIA YES WE DO
AND WE ARE WORRIED ABOUT IT ALL
RIGHT AS WELL SO YOU'RE LOOKING
TO. LANA FROM PEOPLE ONCE YOU
THEM FROM BILL GATES. THANK YOU
CAN YOU CAN YOU PLEASE READ ON.
YOU. FOUR FORTY MILLION ITEMS.
PLEASE OPERATOR IT'S BEEN A
MINUTE. NINE FORTY NINE YOUR
LINE IS OPEN PLEASE GO AHEAD.
HI LARA AND THEN ON THE. WELL
THEY- WERE COALITION OF FORTY
HERE ORGANIZATIONS WANT TO WORK
TOGETHER WITH COMMUNITY GROUPS
LABOR. AND YOU NEED TO BE AN
ENVIRONMENTAL HOUSING PROGRAM
BALLOT EVERYONE OF THE ENTIRE
ECONOMY AND I KNEW HOUSING. NEW
HOUSING TO LOW WAGE. WORKERS AT
SCALE. A LETTER AND DIFFERENT
OF HOUSING WHAT IF SOMEBODY
THAT EVEN. AND THE ONE THING OR
NOT THAT. A VERY EXCITING AND
AS YOU ALL KNOW A LOT. ABOUT
THE MILLION HOUSING RIGHT IT-
VERY EVEN IF WORKING WITH YOU
KNOW TO REALIZE ON HOUSING. IN
A STATE I THINK I. THANK YOU
NEXT CALL. MY FIFTY FIVE UNITED
PLEASE GO AHEAD. YEAH MALES ON
THE LEGISLATURE EIGHT WHO BOTH
REMAIN YEAH POLITICAL AS
CRITICAL FOR THE CREATION OF A
HALF. IT IS IMPORTANT TO ME- AS
YOU KNOW ROUND OF WE DON'T HAVE
EITHER LOCATION SET UP OLD
GOING. LEGAL YOU KNOW HOW BY WE
INNOVATORS WHO COMMITTEE TO GO
THE BEST AROUND HELLO MY RATE.
FOR CYNICAL THIRD OF THE IDEA
THAT PREVENT SAY WE FORWARD WHO
WILL WITH THE SAME NAY READER.
AND I. HOW THANK YOU. THANK YOU
NEXT. MY IN YOUR LIFE IS OPEN
INCLUDING AHEAD. MY SEVEN YOU
MAY BE ON PLEASE GO AHEAD YOUR
LINE IS. MOVING ON TO THE LINE
FORTY SIX LINE FORTY SIX YOUR
LINE IS OPEN PLEASE GO AHEAD.
THANK YOU SO MUCH MEMBERS OF
THIS- HE AND CHAIRPERSON AND
MEMBERS MY NAME IS LISA DIDN'T
RETURN ITEM HIGH HUMIDITY
COMMUNITY OF CULVER CITY ON THE
WEST SIDE OF LOS ANGELES. AND
I'M A PART OF ALONE SHARE WITH
OTHERS- THE GRASSROOTS GROUP
GRASSROOTS MEDICAL CITY FOR THE
HOME WE'RE EXTREMELY EXCITED
ABOUT THE OPPORTUNITIES THAT
YOU ARE PROVIDING US WITH A
GLIMPSE OF THAT PRESENTATION UP
SOCIAL HOUSING TODAY INSTEAD OF
ADDING A LITTLE WEIRD FOR
AMERICA. OTHER STATES AND
COUNTRIES AND IT'S REALLY
IMPORTANT- THAT WE WORK
TOGETHER TO REALIZE THE HUMAN
BENEFITS OF SOCIAL HOUSING TO
ADDRESS RACIAL AND ECONOMIC
JUSTICE THAT. IS A- ASKED AND
ANSWERED WHAT IS TODAY. HE NEED.
TO THE NEXT DUE TO SOME OTHER
TODAY. AND OTHER WONDERFUL
IMPORTANT MEETING YOU CAN
BENEFIT TO WORK. REALLY THAT
THE BUILDING THAT HAPPENED.
YEAH ST ALL PRO THAT WE CAN
HELP TO ADDRESS CLIMATE. REALLY
APPRECIATE YOUR THAN ANY SORT
OF THE THAT YOU ARE EXPLORING
IN CENTERVILLE HUSING THANK
YOU SO MUCH FOR YOUR LEADERSHIP
WE WELCOME THE MORNING PAPERS
THANK YOU SO MUCH. MY THREE
YEAR LITTLE. YEAH CALORIMETER
COUNTY THROUGH THE MONEY OKAY I
DO NOT AGREE WITH EIGHTEEN
CREATED THEM ON SOCIAL HOUSING
HOMEOWNERSHIP IS THE AMERICAN
DREAM CALIFORNIA'S OVER THE
PRICE AND THERE IS A SHORTAGE
OF AFFORDABLE HOUSING WE CAN
HAVE AFFORDABLE HOUSING
PROGRAMS THAT CURRENTLY
RESTRICTING YOUR TO HOMEOWNERS
WHEN THEY IN THEIR OLD
SHROUDING. IT SHOULD NOT BE ALL
THAT. DON'T YOU WANT TO COME.
HOMEOWNERSHIP HANDLE THE BORDER
CREDIT NOT AYE HIGH TO GO ANY
GOLD REAL ESTATE THIS IS A
POLITICAL HI. SHOULD NOT HAVE
TO WORRY ABOUT MORE GOVERNMENT
OVER REACH RAN GRAB WE DO NOT
SHE FORCED THANK YOU. SEE.
THANK YOU NEXT COMMENT PLEASE.
MY FOR YOUR LINE OF OPEN
INCLUDING GO AHEAD. YEAH IN BUT
A YELL I AM A NUMBER- AND WITH
A ACTION I AM EXTREMELY EXCITED
TO HEAR ABOUT SORT OF HOUSING
AND KIND OF LOCAL OF THE PORT
OF THE- GATHERING- AGAIN A MANY
PEOPLE HAVE MENTIONED BEFORE
BUT IT'S IMPORTANT THAT WE NOT
ONLY CREATE- AWAY. TO THE
THINKING REALLY. THREE LOW- YOU
KNOW- ACCESSIBLE- AND ENERGY
EFFICIENT HIGHLY BEGINNING TIME
IT HAVE TO COME A LONG WAY
TENANTS RIGHT AND ABILITY AND
THE ABILITY. TO SUPPORT ANY-
KIND OF THE DOMINANT- I'M
REALLY EXCITED HERE- YOU KNOW
ALL THE OLD EXAMPLES FROM OTHER
COUNTRIES AND ITALY AND CORN
THAT WAS MENTIONED BY THE
PRESIDENT OF THE N. A- ABOUT
TIMING INCLUDED HOUSING WITH
OTHER SERVICES THAT WILL ALLOW
PEOPLE TO FLOURISH. RIDE BUT
EMILY. HAD ANY COMMERCIAL
HOLDINGS MANY. YOU NEXT TO
SPEAKER. MY SIXTY YOUR LITTLE
PLEASE AHEAD. I THANK YOU MY
NAME'S GREG ABBOTT
AUTOMATICALLY GOING TO BE SAFER
AND I JUST WANT TO COMMEND THE
COMMITTEE MEETING AND I WANT TO
THANK- I. AM AWARE- GOOD
SHARING THE COMMITTEE- SO WHAT
DO YOU THINK IRWIN HAWK ABOUT.
YOU'RE GONNA WE THOUGHT IT
WOULD HAVE HAD A DREAM AND LOOK
WHERE WE ARE THANK YOU I'M NOT
A WEAKER LEFTOVERS- SO I WANTED
TO BE I. CERVANTES HITTING AN
ALL THE ABOVE APPROACH-
MARKETABLE YEAH A LOT OF MODEL.
IN BERKLEY SERVICES ONE KNOW
THAT WE'RE HERE TO SUPPORT YOU
KNOW IF YOU NEED HELP WITH
RESEARCH ON I ALSO WANT TO SAY
THAT WOULD BE GREAT TO SEE YOU
AS A MINNESOTA BROWN TOLD
ANAHIT ACTIVITY OWNERSHIP-
ENCOURAGING MIXED INCOME
DEVELOPMENTS- THE- MEDIAN BAY
AREA HOME PRICES. ACROSS THE
COUNTY IS ONE POINT TWO THREE
FIVE MILLION DOLLARS AND I
THINK SO HOLDING IT IN A WAY TO
SEND THE SIGNAL FOR PEOPLE LIKE
ME YOUNG PEOPLE IMMIGRANTS-
THIS IS THE ONLY WAY ONLY GOLD
TO BE ALL YOU KNOW THE BODY
COMING HERE. SHORTLY AND NO
LONGER FACES LIKE ON SO I DON'T
THANK YOU FOR ALL YOUR WORK AND
WE'RE HERE TO HELP. THANK. IN
ORDER TO UNIVERSITY WATER GOOD
ROADS NOT A LITTLE BETTER AND
ACTUALLY. YOU'RE A GOOD GIRL WE
MET IT ACTED UNLAWFULLY OUT
INSPECTOR MICHAEL ROBIN IN THE-
MORNING- EXFOLIATION THAT HAD.
EVERYBODY BAKER BE LIKE LACTOSE
RIGHT AROUND HOMELESSNESS THE
THING. BUDGET REMOVAL OUT
DETAILS WITH ALL THAT OUT AND
MORE. WE'RE GONNA BRING THE
TABLE WORK ON THE MEDICAL WE DO
NOT NOT ALLOWING. THE HORRIBLE.
MERMAID AMERICANS WILL THANK
ALL BE EATING A LITTLE WORKING.
EIGHT ACTUALLY I'M VERY EXCITED
THAT WE'RE GOING HOME HOME AS
QUICKLY AS YOU CAN IMAGINE WE
ARE GOING ON THE LETTER AT OVER
EIGHTY FIVE OR YOU CAN SIGN ON
TO. THE LEAD INTO DOUBLE
BECAUSE OF HOW THEY DEMONSTRATE
A LETTER SHOULD BE MODIFIED
CANNOT THE MARKET HE BE
PERMANENTLY AFFORDABLE TO
RESIDENTS AT ALL INCOME LEVELS
AND ALSO TO THE RIGHT IS THE
RIGHT TO PARTICIPATE KINDLY-
NEED FOR IT AND WHAT IT IS LIKE
ANY WILL EXPLORE IN. THE THANK
YOU AND I WE WERE ON A TO GET
TO A- REMOTELY WHO ASKED-
SUBMIT PUBLIC AND THEY DO SO-
ON MY WEBSITE- YOU CAN GO TO.
AS A FIFTEEN DOT A. S. M. D. C.
DOT ORG AND CLICK ON CONTACT US
SENATE MEMBER WORKS AND WILL BE
TAKING PUBLIC COMMENT THERE- I
ALSO KNOW MANY OF THE FOLKS
THAT WERE IN THE ROOM TODAY
WHO. PROBABLY PERSONALLY ON MY
CELL PHONE NUMBER- THAT'S
ALWAYS IN A GOOD WAY AND THEN
WE HAVE FOLKS REMOTELY ALSO THE
KNOW MYSELF MY STAFF AND MY
COLLEAGUES WERE ALL AVAILABLE-
TO HEAR YOU ALL OUT AND I ALSO-
WE'RE GONNA WRAP UP NOW I WANT
TO GIVE MY COLLEAGUES THE TIME
JUST BECAUSE WELL BUT- YOU KNOW
I JUST WANT TO SAY. THE
FEEDBACK FROM- DIVERSE
STAKEHOLDERS IS ABSOLUTELY
CRITICAL TO THIS- I KNOW
MEMBERS MANY OF RT SUBMITTED
LETTERS WE WELCOME THAT WE
WELCOME THE CONVERSATION- WE
MAY NOT ALL AGREE ON EVERYTHING
BUT I KNOW WE HAVE A SHARED
VISION OF- CREATING MORE
HOUSING FOR. PEOPLE IN OUR
COMMUNITIES WHO NEED IT- AND
THAT'S WHAT THIS IS ABOUT AND
SO I LOOK FORWARD TO THE
CONVERSATION I APPRECIATE THE
DIALOGUE WHETHER WE AGREE OR
DISAGREE I ALWAYS WELCOME IN MY
OFFICE I KNOW MY COLLEAGUES DO
AS WELL I WANT TO WORK- HAND IN
HAND WITH WITH MANY BE THAT ARE
HERE TODAY TO SOLVE THIS
PROBLEM SO. THANK YOU ALL WHO
WHO CAME AND PARTICIPATED I'M
SORRY WE COULDN'T GET TO ALL
THE PUBLIC COMMENT. I WILL BE
HAVING AT LEAST THREE MORE
HEARINGS ON SOCIAL HOUSING- IN
THE COMING FUTURE FOR THE
SELECT COMMITTEE WITH THE GOAL
AGAIN OF. DEVELOPING A
FRAMEWORK A LEGISLATIVE
FRAMEWORK THAT WE CAN THEN MOVE
FORWARD- AND ESTABLISHING I'M
SOME SOLUTIONS TO OUR HOUSING
CRISIS- I AM DEEPLY
APPRECIATIVE OF MY COLLEAGUES
PARTICIPATION AND WANT TO GIVE
THEM THE OPPORTUNITY. FOR SOME
CLOSING. REMARKS I WILL START
WITH ASSEMBLY MEMBER LEE. WELL
FIRST OFF THANKS TO SIMILAR.
FOR CREATING INFORMING THE
SLICKNESS OF HOUSING AND- I
BRING THIS ISSUE INTO THE MAIN
LINE. I APPRECIATE ALL THE
FEEDBACK WE HEARD FROM THE
PUBLIC TODAY WHETHER BE VIRTUAL
OR IN PERSON TODAY AND- WANTS
YOU ALL TO KNOW THAT THAT
FEEDBACK. IS VERY WELL TAKEN.
IT WAS. SIMILAR WITH THE NUYS
INTENTION. WHEN INTRODUCED A
SOCIAL HOUSING ACT LAST YEAR
WHICH WE ARE STILL WORKING ON
AND WORKING WITH A LOT OF
STAKEHOLDERS THE SAME PEOPLE
THAT HAVE. SPOKEN TO US. TO
REALLY INTENTIONALLY BUILD
SOCIAL HOUSING VISION FROM THE
GROUND UP TOGETHER. AND IT'S
CERTAINLY THE KIND OF FEEDBACK
YOU'RE HEARING TODAY THAT WE'RE
GOING TO CORPORATE INTO THE
BILL. AND AS WE GO THROUGH THIS
PROCESS OF THE SELECT COMMITTEE
HEARINGS AND LEARN FROM.
EXPERTS ACROSS THE WORLD TO
TODAY WE DID EUROPE AND MEXICO
AND HOPEFULLY WE WILL HAVE
TAIWAN AND SINGAPORE AS WELL.
OTHER GREAT. ASIAN THE EXAMPLES
EXCELLENCE- WE'RE GONNA
CORPORATE WHAT. WORKED REALLY
WELL OVER THERE BUT WHAT CAN WE
ADAPT HERE AND LEARNING FROM
OUR OWN MISTAKES IS KIND OF
IMPORTANT. BUT AS YOU HEARD YOU
KNOW THERE ARE SO MANY GREAT
AVENUES AND SO MANY THINGS YOU
CAN LEARN. TO MAKE SURE WE HAVE
DEEPLY AFFORDABLE. PERMANENT
HOUSING IN CALIFORNIA CAN BE
OFF THE SPECULUM MARKET. I
THINK WE CAN DO IN CALIFORNIA
BUT IT'S GONNA TAKE ALL OF OUR
EFFORTS TOGETHER SO AGAIN I
APPLAUD. MY COLLEAGUES. IN HER
HISTORY HERE. FOR HOSTESS AND
LOOK FOR THE FUTURE COMMITTEE
MEETINGS. THANK YOU SOME NUMBER
LEE AND ASSEMBLYMEMBER BONTA. I
WANT TO ADD ALSO THINK- CHAIR
WICKS FOR CONVENING THIS SELECT
COMMITTEE AND FOR. ASSEMBLY
MEMBER WITH LEE MY COLLEAGUE
FOR ENSURING THAT THIS BECOMES
A TOPIC OF GREAT DISCUSSION AND
ACTION FOR THE STATE
LEGISLATURE. I CERTAINLY
APPRECIATED LEARNING OVER THE
COURSE OF THIS. HEARING OF THE
TENETS THAT REALLY FOCUSED ON
CONSTRUCTION FINANCING.
MANAGEMENT AND- AND LOCATION IN
THAT AS WELL. AND APPRECIATED
THE FEEDBACK THAT WE HEARD FROM
STAKEHOLDERS. AT THAT REALLY
EMPHASIZE THAT WE CAN'T BUILD A
SOCIAL HOUSING IMPACT ENSURE
ADDITIONAL HOUSING PRODUCTION.
ON THE BACKS OF ON THE BACK TO
PEOPLE SO I THINK UP A HUGE
COMPONENT OF THIS FOR ME IN
CONSIDERATION IS JUST ENSURING
THAT- OUR- OUR. WORKFORCES IS
TAKING CARE OF AS WE CONTINUE
ENSURE THAT WE- BUILD OUT THAT.
HOUSING THAT WE NEED THROUGH
THE PARTICULAR MODEL. I ALSO
JUST WANTED TO HIGHLIGHT AND
APPRECIATE THE PUBLIC F.
FEEDBACK THAT WE GOT. A TO IT
NOT- NOT DISCOUNT DIDN'T REALLY
TO ALSO BE ABLE TO CENTER. IN
THAT IN OUR- PURSUITS ON SOCIAL
HOUSING TO ENSURE THAT WE HAVE
A FOCUS ON- ON PROTECTIONS FOR
TENANTS AND RENTERS WITHIN
THAT. AND ALSO TO FOCUS SOME OF
OUR ENERGY ON ON THE
PRESERVATION OF HOUSING WITHIN
THIS CONCEPT SO. I'M VERY
APPRECIATIVE OF THE SPACE AT
THIS IS CREATING. WE'RE AT A
MOMENT WHERE WE ABSOLUTELY NEED
BOLD ACTION FROM THIS
CALIFORNIA STATE LEGISLATURE.
AND I REALLY APPRECIATE THAT
ASSEMBLY MEMBER WORKS CREATING
THE SPACE FOR US TO BE ABLE TO.
HAVE A FULL CONVERSATIONS
AROUND THIS THANK YOU. THANK
YOU AND I LOOK FORWARD TO
FURTHER CONVERSATIONS AND WITH
THAT THIS MEETING IS ADJOURNED.